<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
<Return xmlns="http://www.irs.gov/efile" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://www.irs.gov/efile" returnVersion="2022v5.0">
  <ReturnHeader binaryAttachmentCnt="0">
    <ReturnTs>2023-11-03T08:02:42-05:00</ReturnTs>
    <TaxPeriodEndDt>2023-06-30</TaxPeriodEndDt>
    <PreparerFirmGrp>
      <PreparerFirmEIN>582676261</PreparerFirmEIN>
      <PreparerFirmName>
        <BusinessNameLine1Txt>Rogers &amp; Company PLLC</BusinessNameLine1Txt>
      </PreparerFirmName>
      <PreparerUSAddress>
        <AddressLine1Txt>8300 Boone Boulevard Suite 600</AddressLine1Txt>
        <CityNm>Vienna</CityNm>
        <StateAbbreviationCd>VA</StateAbbreviationCd>
        <ZIPCd>22182</ZIPCd>
      </PreparerUSAddress>
    </PreparerFirmGrp>
    <ReturnTypeCd>990</ReturnTypeCd>
    <TaxPeriodBeginDt>2022-07-01</TaxPeriodBeginDt>
    <Filer>
      <EIN>942197343</EIN>
      <BusinessName>
        <BusinessNameLine1Txt>Pacific Legal Foundation</BusinessNameLine1Txt>
      </BusinessName>
      <BusinessNameControlTxt>PACI</BusinessNameControlTxt>
      <PhoneNum>9164197111</PhoneNum>
      <USAddress>
        <AddressLine1Txt>555 Capitol Mall Suite 1290</AddressLine1Txt>
        <CityNm>Sacramento</CityNm>
        <StateAbbreviationCd>CA</StateAbbreviationCd>
        <ZIPCd>958144605</ZIPCd>
      </USAddress>
    </Filer>
    <BusinessOfficerGrp>
      <PersonNm>Steven D Anderson</PersonNm>
      <PersonTitleTxt>President/CEO</PersonTitleTxt>
      <PhoneNum>9164197111</PhoneNum>
      <SignatureDt>2023-10-31</SignatureDt>
      <DiscussWithPaidPreparerInd>1</DiscussWithPaidPreparerInd>
    </BusinessOfficerGrp>
    <SigningOfficerGrp>
      <PersonFullName>
        <PersonFirstNm>Steven</PersonFirstNm>
        <PersonLastNm>Anderson</PersonLastNm>
      </PersonFullName>
      <SSN>XXX-XX-XXXX</SSN>
    </SigningOfficerGrp>
    <IRSResponsiblePrtyInfoCurrInd>1</IRSResponsiblePrtyInfoCurrInd>
    <PreparerPersonGrp>
      <PreparerPersonNm>Yong Zhang CPA</PreparerPersonNm>
      <PTIN>P01249785</PTIN>
      <PhoneNum>7038930300</PhoneNum>
      <PreparationDt>2023-10-30</PreparationDt>
    </PreparerPersonGrp>
    <AdditionalFilerInformation>
      <TrustedCustomerGrp>
        <TrustedCustomerCd>2</TrustedCustomerCd>
        <AuthenticationAssuranceLevelCd>AAL1</AuthenticationAssuranceLevelCd>
        <IdentityAssuranceLevelCd>IAL1</IdentityAssuranceLevelCd>
      </TrustedCustomerGrp>
    </AdditionalFilerInformation>
    <TaxYr>2022</TaxYr>
    <BuildTS>2023-04-26 12:10:37Z</BuildTS>
  </ReturnHeader>
  <ReturnData documentCnt="10">
    <IRS990 documentId="RetDoc1038000001" referenceDocumentId="RetDoc1044400001">
      <PrincipalOfficerNm>Steven D Anderson</PrincipalOfficerNm>
      <USAddress>
        <AddressLine1Txt>555 Capitol Mall Suite 1290</AddressLine1Txt>
        <CityNm>Sacramento</CityNm>
        <StateAbbreviationCd>CA</StateAbbreviationCd>
        <ZIPCd>958144605</ZIPCd>
      </USAddress>
      <GrossReceiptsAmt>44593393</GrossReceiptsAmt>
      <GroupReturnForAffiliatesInd>0</GroupReturnForAffiliatesInd>
      <Organization501c3Ind>X</Organization501c3Ind>
      <WebsiteAddressTxt>https://pacificlegal.org/</WebsiteAddressTxt>
      <TypeOfOrganizationCorpInd>X</TypeOfOrganizationCorpInd>
      <FormationYr>1973</FormationYr>
      <LegalDomicileStateCd>CA</LegalDomicileStateCd>
      <ActivityOrMissionDesc>To defend liberty and justice for all. See Schedule O for full mission.</ActivityOrMissionDesc>
      <VotingMembersGoverningBodyCnt>18</VotingMembersGoverningBodyCnt>
      <VotingMembersIndependentCnt>18</VotingMembersIndependentCnt>
      <TotalEmployeeCnt>128</TotalEmployeeCnt>
      <TotalVolunteersCnt>18</TotalVolunteersCnt>
      <TotalGrossUBIAmt>0</TotalGrossUBIAmt>
      <NetUnrelatedBusTxblIncmAmt>0</NetUnrelatedBusTxblIncmAmt>
      <PYContributionsGrantsAmt>26374951</PYContributionsGrantsAmt>
      <CYContributionsGrantsAmt>21771790</CYContributionsGrantsAmt>
      <PYProgramServiceRevenueAmt>126573</PYProgramServiceRevenueAmt>
      <CYProgramServiceRevenueAmt>1128139</CYProgramServiceRevenueAmt>
      <PYInvestmentIncomeAmt>1632962</PYInvestmentIncomeAmt>
      <CYInvestmentIncomeAmt>2137389</CYInvestmentIncomeAmt>
      <PYOtherRevenueAmt>111055</PYOtherRevenueAmt>
      <CYOtherRevenueAmt>32006</CYOtherRevenueAmt>
      <PYTotalRevenueAmt>28245541</PYTotalRevenueAmt>
      <CYTotalRevenueAmt>25069324</CYTotalRevenueAmt>
      <PYGrantsAndSimilarPaidAmt>0</PYGrantsAndSimilarPaidAmt>
      <CYGrantsAndSimilarPaidAmt>120000</CYGrantsAndSimilarPaidAmt>
      <PYBenefitsPaidToMembersAmt>0</PYBenefitsPaidToMembersAmt>
      <CYBenefitsPaidToMembersAmt>0</CYBenefitsPaidToMembersAmt>
      <PYSalariesCompEmpBnftPaidAmt>14671549</PYSalariesCompEmpBnftPaidAmt>
      <CYSalariesCompEmpBnftPaidAmt>17653078</CYSalariesCompEmpBnftPaidAmt>
      <PYTotalProfFndrsngExpnsAmt>0</PYTotalProfFndrsngExpnsAmt>
      <CYTotalProfFndrsngExpnsAmt>0</CYTotalProfFndrsngExpnsAmt>
      <CYTotalFundraisingExpenseAmt>2030290</CYTotalFundraisingExpenseAmt>
      <PYOtherExpensesAmt>5532125</PYOtherExpensesAmt>
      <CYOtherExpensesAmt>7789079</CYOtherExpensesAmt>
      <PYTotalExpensesAmt>20203674</PYTotalExpensesAmt>
      <CYTotalExpensesAmt>25562157</CYTotalExpensesAmt>
      <PYRevenuesLessExpensesAmt>8041867</PYRevenuesLessExpensesAmt>
      <CYRevenuesLessExpensesAmt>-492833</CYRevenuesLessExpensesAmt>
      <TotalAssetsBOYAmt>76776179</TotalAssetsBOYAmt>
      <TotalAssetsEOYAmt>85220260</TotalAssetsEOYAmt>
      <TotalLiabilitiesBOYAmt>4859691</TotalLiabilitiesBOYAmt>
      <TotalLiabilitiesEOYAmt>7175804</TotalLiabilitiesEOYAmt>
      <NetAssetsOrFundBalancesBOYAmt>71916488</NetAssetsOrFundBalancesBOYAmt>
      <NetAssetsOrFundBalancesEOYAmt>78044456</NetAssetsOrFundBalancesEOYAmt>
      <InfoInScheduleOPartIIIInd>X</InfoInScheduleOPartIIIInd>
      <MissionDesc>Pacific Legal Foundation (PLF) litigates nationwide to secure all Americans' inalienable rights to live responsibly and productively in their pursuit of happiness. See Schedule O for full mission</MissionDesc>
      <SignificantNewProgramSrvcInd>0</SignificantNewProgramSrvcInd>
      <SignificantChangeInd>0</SignificantChangeInd>
      <ExpenseAmt>20878170</ExpenseAmt>
      <GrantAmt>120000</GrantAmt>
      <RevenueAmt>1128139</RevenueAmt>
      <Desc>Each year, PLF represents hundreds of Americans, free of charge, who seek to improve their lives but are stymied by government. We give them their day in court to vindicate their rights and set a lasting precedent to protect everyone else. See Schedule O for a complete list of cases litigated during the fiscal year ended June 30, 2023.</Desc>
      <TotalProgramServiceExpensesAmt>20878170</TotalProgramServiceExpensesAmt>
      <DescribedInSection501c3Ind referenceDocumentId="RetDoc1039100001">1</DescribedInSection501c3Ind>
      <ScheduleBRequiredInd referenceDocumentId="RetDoc1234500001">1</ScheduleBRequiredInd>
      <PoliticalCampaignActyInd referenceDocumentId="RetDoc1039600001">0</PoliticalCampaignActyInd>
      <LobbyingActivitiesInd referenceDocumentId="RetDoc1039600001">1</LobbyingActivitiesInd>
      <SubjectToProxyTaxInd referenceDocumentId="RetDoc1039600001">0</SubjectToProxyTaxInd>
      <DonorAdvisedFundInd referenceDocumentId="RetDoc1040000001">0</DonorAdvisedFundInd>
      <ConservationEasementsInd referenceDocumentId="RetDoc1040000001">0</ConservationEasementsInd>
      <CollectionsOfArtInd referenceDocumentId="RetDoc1040000001">0</CollectionsOfArtInd>
      <CreditCounselingInd referenceDocumentId="RetDoc1040000001">0</CreditCounselingInd>
      <DonorRstrOrQuasiEndowmentsInd>1</DonorRstrOrQuasiEndowmentsInd>
      <ReportLandBuildingEquipmentInd referenceDocumentId="RetDoc1040000001">1</ReportLandBuildingEquipmentInd>
      <ReportInvestmentsOtherSecInd referenceDocumentId="RetDoc1040000001">1</ReportInvestmentsOtherSecInd>
      <ReportProgramRelatedInvstInd referenceDocumentId="RetDoc1040000001">0</ReportProgramRelatedInvstInd>
      <ReportOtherAssetsInd referenceDocumentId="RetDoc1040000001">1</ReportOtherAssetsInd>
      <ReportOtherLiabilitiesInd referenceDocumentId="RetDoc1040000001">1</ReportOtherLiabilitiesInd>
      <IncludeFIN48FootnoteInd referenceDocumentId="RetDoc1040000001">1</IncludeFIN48FootnoteInd>
      <IndependentAuditFinclStmtInd referenceDocumentId="RetDoc1040000001">1</IndependentAuditFinclStmtInd>
      <ConsolidatedAuditFinclStmtInd referenceDocumentId="RetDoc1040000001">0</ConsolidatedAuditFinclStmtInd>
      <SchoolOperatingInd>0</SchoolOperatingInd>
      <ForeignOfficeInd>0</ForeignOfficeInd>
      <ForeignActivitiesInd>0</ForeignActivitiesInd>
      <MoreThan5000KToOrgInd>0</MoreThan5000KToOrgInd>
      <MoreThan5000KToIndividualsInd>0</MoreThan5000KToIndividualsInd>
      <ProfessionalFundraisingInd>0</ProfessionalFundraisingInd>
      <FundraisingActivitiesInd>0</FundraisingActivitiesInd>
      <GamingActivitiesInd>0</GamingActivitiesInd>
      <OperateHospitalInd>0</OperateHospitalInd>
      <GrantsToOrganizationsInd referenceDocumentId="RetDoc1041900001">1</GrantsToOrganizationsInd>
      <GrantsToIndividualsInd referenceDocumentId="RetDoc1041900001">0</GrantsToIndividualsInd>
      <ScheduleJRequiredInd referenceDocumentId="RetDoc1042400001">1</ScheduleJRequiredInd>
      <TaxExemptBondsInd>0</TaxExemptBondsInd>
      <EngagedInExcessBenefitTransInd>0</EngagedInExcessBenefitTransInd>
      <PYExcessBenefitTransInd>0</PYExcessBenefitTransInd>
      <LoanOutstandingInd>0</LoanOutstandingInd>
      <GrantToRelatedPersonInd>0</GrantToRelatedPersonInd>
      <BusinessRlnWithOrgMemInd>0</BusinessRlnWithOrgMemInd>
      <BusinessRlnWithFamMemInd>0</BusinessRlnWithFamMemInd>
      <BusinessRlnWith35CtrlEntInd>0</BusinessRlnWith35CtrlEntInd>
      <DeductibleNonCashContriInd referenceDocumentId="RetDoc1042900001">1</DeductibleNonCashContriInd>
      <DeductibleArtContributionInd referenceDocumentId="RetDoc1042900001">0</DeductibleArtContributionInd>
      <TerminateOperationsInd>0</TerminateOperationsInd>
      <PartialLiquidationInd>0</PartialLiquidationInd>
      <DisregardedEntityInd referenceDocumentId="RetDoc1043400001">1</DisregardedEntityInd>
      <RelatedEntityInd referenceDocumentId="RetDoc1043400001">0</RelatedEntityInd>
      <RelatedOrganizationCtrlEntInd>0</RelatedOrganizationCtrlEntInd>
      <TrnsfrExmptNonChrtblRltdOrgInd referenceDocumentId="RetDoc1043400001">0</TrnsfrExmptNonChrtblRltdOrgInd>
      <ActivitiesConductedPrtshpInd referenceDocumentId="RetDoc1043400001">0</ActivitiesConductedPrtshpInd>
      <ScheduleORequiredInd>1</ScheduleORequiredInd>
      <IRPDocumentCnt>75</IRPDocumentCnt>
      <IRPDocumentW2GCnt>0</IRPDocumentW2GCnt>
      <BackupWthldComplianceInd>1</BackupWthldComplianceInd>
      <EmployeeCnt>128</EmployeeCnt>
      <EmploymentTaxReturnsFiledInd>1</EmploymentTaxReturnsFiledInd>
      <UnrelatedBusIncmOverLimitInd>0</UnrelatedBusIncmOverLimitInd>
      <ForeignFinancialAccountInd>0</ForeignFinancialAccountInd>
      <ProhibitedTaxShelterTransInd>0</ProhibitedTaxShelterTransInd>
      <TaxablePartyNotificationInd>0</TaxablePartyNotificationInd>
      <NondeductibleContributionsInd>0</NondeductibleContributionsInd>
      <QuidProQuoContributionsInd>0</QuidProQuoContributionsInd>
      <Form8282PropertyDisposedOfInd>0</Form8282PropertyDisposedOfInd>
      <RcvFndsToPayPrsnlBnftCntrctInd>0</RcvFndsToPayPrsnlBnftCntrctInd>
      <PayPremiumsPrsnlBnftCntrctInd>0</PayPremiumsPrsnlBnftCntrctInd>
      <IndoorTanningServicesInd>0</IndoorTanningServicesInd>
      <SubjToTaxRmnrtnExPrchtPymtInd>0</SubjToTaxRmnrtnExPrchtPymtInd>
      <SubjectToExcsTaxNetInvstIncInd>0</SubjectToExcsTaxNetInvstIncInd>
      <InfoInScheduleOPartVIInd>X</InfoInScheduleOPartVIInd>
      <GoverningBodyVotingMembersCnt>18</GoverningBodyVotingMembersCnt>
      <IndependentVotingMemberCnt>18</IndependentVotingMemberCnt>
      <FamilyOrBusinessRlnInd>0</FamilyOrBusinessRlnInd>
      <DelegationOfMgmtDutiesInd>0</DelegationOfMgmtDutiesInd>
      <ChangeToOrgDocumentsInd>0</ChangeToOrgDocumentsInd>
      <MaterialDiversionOrMisuseInd>0</MaterialDiversionOrMisuseInd>
      <MembersOrStockholdersInd>0</MembersOrStockholdersInd>
      <ElectionOfBoardMembersInd>0</ElectionOfBoardMembersInd>
      <DecisionsSubjectToApprovaInd>0</DecisionsSubjectToApprovaInd>
      <MinutesOfGoverningBodyInd>1</MinutesOfGoverningBodyInd>
      <MinutesOfCommitteesInd>1</MinutesOfCommitteesInd>
      <OfficerMailingAddressInd>0</OfficerMailingAddressInd>
      <LocalChaptersInd>0</LocalChaptersInd>
      <Form990ProvidedToGvrnBodyInd>1</Form990ProvidedToGvrnBodyInd>
      <ConflictOfInterestPolicyInd>1</ConflictOfInterestPolicyInd>
      <AnnualDisclosureCoveredPrsnInd>1</AnnualDisclosureCoveredPrsnInd>
      <RegularMonitoringEnfrcInd>1</RegularMonitoringEnfrcInd>
      <WhistleblowerPolicyInd>1</WhistleblowerPolicyInd>
      <DocumentRetentionPolicyInd>1</DocumentRetentionPolicyInd>
      <CompensationProcessCEOInd>1</CompensationProcessCEOInd>
      <CompensationProcessOtherInd>1</CompensationProcessOtherInd>
      <InvestmentInJointVentureInd>0</InvestmentInJointVentureInd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>AL</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>AK</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>AZ</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>AR</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>CA</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>CO</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>CT</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>DC</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>FL</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>GA</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>HI</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>IL</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>KS</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>KY</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>LA</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>ME</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>MD</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>MA</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>MI</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>MN</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>MS</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>MO</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>NH</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>NJ</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>NM</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>NY</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>NC</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>ND</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>OH</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>OK</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>OR</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>PA</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>RI</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>SC</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>TN</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>UT</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>VA</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>WA</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>WV</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>WI</StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd>
      <OwnWebsiteInd>X</OwnWebsiteInd>
      <UponRequestInd>X</UponRequestInd>
      <BooksInCareOfDetail>
        <BusinessName>
          <BusinessNameLine1Txt>Charles E Wilcox IV</BusinessNameLine1Txt>
        </BusinessName>
        <PhoneNum>9164197111</PhoneNum>
        <USAddress>
          <AddressLine1Txt>555 Capitol Mall Suite 1290</AddressLine1Txt>
          <CityNm>Sacramento</CityNm>
          <StateAbbreviationCd>CA</StateAbbreviationCd>
          <ZIPCd>958144605</ZIPCd>
        </USAddress>
      </BooksInCareOfDetail>
      <Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
        <PersonNm>Brian G Cartwright</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Chair of the Board</TitleTxt>
        <AverageHoursPerWeekRt>1.00</AverageHoursPerWeekRt>
        <IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>X</IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>
        <OfficerInd>X</OfficerInd>
        <ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
        <ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationAmt>0</OtherCompensationAmt>
      </Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
      <Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
        <PersonNm>Robert D Connors</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Vice Chair</TitleTxt>
        <AverageHoursPerWeekRt>1.00</AverageHoursPerWeekRt>
        <IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>X</IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>
        <OfficerInd>X</OfficerInd>
        <ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
        <ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationAmt>0</OtherCompensationAmt>
      </Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
      <Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
        <PersonNm>Robert K Best</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Trustee</TitleTxt>
        <AverageHoursPerWeekRt>1.00</AverageHoursPerWeekRt>
        <IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>X</IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>
        <ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
        <ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationAmt>0</OtherCompensationAmt>
      </Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
      <Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
        <PersonNm>Ross Borba Jr</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Trustee</TitleTxt>
        <AverageHoursPerWeekRt>1.00</AverageHoursPerWeekRt>
        <IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>X</IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>
        <ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
        <ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationAmt>0</OtherCompensationAmt>
      </Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
      <Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
        <PersonNm>Amy Brigham Boulris</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Trustee</TitleTxt>
        <AverageHoursPerWeekRt>1.00</AverageHoursPerWeekRt>
        <IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>X</IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>
        <ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
        <ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationAmt>0</OtherCompensationAmt>
      </Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
      <Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
        <PersonNm>James L Cloud</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Trustee</TitleTxt>
        <AverageHoursPerWeekRt>1.00</AverageHoursPerWeekRt>
        <IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>X</IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>
        <ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
        <ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationAmt>0</OtherCompensationAmt>
      </Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
      <Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
        <PersonNm>Greg M Evans</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Trustee</TitleTxt>
        <AverageHoursPerWeekRt>1.00</AverageHoursPerWeekRt>
        <IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>X</IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>
        <ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
        <ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationAmt>0</OtherCompensationAmt>
      </Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
      <Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
        <PersonNm>Len Frank</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Trustee</TitleTxt>
        <AverageHoursPerWeekRt>1.00</AverageHoursPerWeekRt>
        <IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>X</IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>
        <ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
        <ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationAmt>0</OtherCompensationAmt>
      </Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
      <Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
        <PersonNm>David Gerson</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Trustee</TitleTxt>
        <AverageHoursPerWeekRt>1.00</AverageHoursPerWeekRt>
        <IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>X</IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>
        <ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
        <ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationAmt>0</OtherCompensationAmt>
      </Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
      <Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
        <PersonNm>John C Harris</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Trustee</TitleTxt>
        <AverageHoursPerWeekRt>1.00</AverageHoursPerWeekRt>
        <IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>X</IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>
        <ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
        <ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationAmt>0</OtherCompensationAmt>
      </Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
      <Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
        <PersonNm>George Kimball</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Trustee</TitleTxt>
        <AverageHoursPerWeekRt>1.00</AverageHoursPerWeekRt>
        <IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>X</IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>
        <ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
        <ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationAmt>0</OtherCompensationAmt>
      </Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
      <Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
        <PersonNm>Carol Platt Liebau</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Trustee</TitleTxt>
        <AverageHoursPerWeekRt>1.00</AverageHoursPerWeekRt>
        <IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>X</IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>
        <ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
        <ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationAmt>0</OtherCompensationAmt>
      </Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
      <Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
        <PersonNm>April J Morris</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Trustee</TitleTxt>
        <AverageHoursPerWeekRt>1.00</AverageHoursPerWeekRt>
        <IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>X</IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>
        <ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
        <ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationAmt>0</OtherCompensationAmt>
      </Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
      <Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
        <PersonNm>Bruce C Smith</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Trustee</TitleTxt>
        <AverageHoursPerWeekRt>1.00</AverageHoursPerWeekRt>
        <IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>X</IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>
        <ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
        <ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationAmt>0</OtherCompensationAmt>
      </Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
      <Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
        <PersonNm>Charles W Trainor</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Trustee</TitleTxt>
        <AverageHoursPerWeekRt>1.00</AverageHoursPerWeekRt>
        <IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>X</IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>
        <ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
        <ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationAmt>0</OtherCompensationAmt>
      </Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
      <Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
        <PersonNm>Ronald E Van Buskirk</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Trustee</TitleTxt>
        <AverageHoursPerWeekRt>1.00</AverageHoursPerWeekRt>
        <IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>X</IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>
        <ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
        <ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationAmt>0</OtherCompensationAmt>
      </Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
      <Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
        <PersonNm>Jeffrey E Warren</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Trustee</TitleTxt>
        <AverageHoursPerWeekRt>1.00</AverageHoursPerWeekRt>
        <IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>X</IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>
        <ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
        <ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationAmt>0</OtherCompensationAmt>
      </Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
      <Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
        <PersonNm>John Yoo</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Trustee</TitleTxt>
        <AverageHoursPerWeekRt>1.00</AverageHoursPerWeekRt>
        <IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>X</IndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd>
        <ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
        <ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationAmt>0</OtherCompensationAmt>
      </Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
      <Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
        <PersonNm>Steven D Anderson</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>President and CEO</TitleTxt>
        <AverageHoursPerWeekRt>37.50</AverageHoursPerWeekRt>
        <OfficerInd>X</OfficerInd>
        <ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>560093</ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
        <ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationAmt>90664</OtherCompensationAmt>
      </Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
      <Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
        <PersonNm>John M Groen</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Executive Vice President</TitleTxt>
        <AverageHoursPerWeekRt>37.50</AverageHoursPerWeekRt>
        <OfficerInd>X</OfficerInd>
        <ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>315234</ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
        <ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationAmt>66570</OtherCompensationAmt>
      </Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
      <Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
        <PersonNm>Larry G Salzman</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Secretary and Director of Litigation</TitleTxt>
        <AverageHoursPerWeekRt>37.50</AverageHoursPerWeekRt>
        <OfficerInd>X</OfficerInd>
        <ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>231367</ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
        <ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationAmt>65335</OtherCompensationAmt>
      </Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
      <Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
        <PersonNm>Charles E Wilcox IV</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Treasurer and CFO/COO</TitleTxt>
        <AverageHoursPerWeekRt>37.50</AverageHoursPerWeekRt>
        <OfficerInd>X</OfficerInd>
        <ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>240130</ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
        <ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationAmt>53459</OtherCompensationAmt>
      </Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
      <Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
        <PersonNm>Todd F Gaziano</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Chief of Legal Policy &amp; Research</TitleTxt>
        <AverageHoursPerWeekRt>37.50</AverageHoursPerWeekRt>
        <HighestCompensatedEmployeeInd>X</HighestCompensatedEmployeeInd>
        <ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>271651</ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
        <ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationAmt>50977</OtherCompensationAmt>
      </Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
      <Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
        <PersonNm>Steve Simpson</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Senior Attorney</TitleTxt>
        <AverageHoursPerWeekRt>37.50</AverageHoursPerWeekRt>
        <HighestCompensatedEmployeeInd>X</HighestCompensatedEmployeeInd>
        <ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>244467</ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
        <ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationAmt>33019</OtherCompensationAmt>
      </Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
      <Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
        <PersonNm>James S Burling</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Vice President Legal Affair</TitleTxt>
        <AverageHoursPerWeekRt>37.50</AverageHoursPerWeekRt>
        <HighestCompensatedEmployeeInd>X</HighestCompensatedEmployeeInd>
        <ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>230251</ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
        <ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationAmt>47644</OtherCompensationAmt>
      </Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
      <Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
        <PersonNm>Damien Schiff</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Senior Attorney</TitleTxt>
        <AverageHoursPerWeekRt>37.50</AverageHoursPerWeekRt>
        <HighestCompensatedEmployeeInd>X</HighestCompensatedEmployeeInd>
        <ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>219008</ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
        <ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationAmt>41418</OtherCompensationAmt>
      </Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
      <Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
        <PersonNm>Joshua Thompson</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Dir.of Equality &amp; Opportunity Litigation</TitleTxt>
        <AverageHoursPerWeekRt>37.50</AverageHoursPerWeekRt>
        <HighestCompensatedEmployeeInd>X</HighestCompensatedEmployeeInd>
        <ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>206322</ReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
        <ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>0</ReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationAmt>50918</OtherCompensationAmt>
      </Form990PartVIISectionAGrp>
      <TotalReportableCompFromOrgAmt>2518523</TotalReportableCompFromOrgAmt>
      <TotReportableCompRltdOrgAmt>0</TotReportableCompRltdOrgAmt>
      <TotalOtherCompensationAmt>500004</TotalOtherCompensationAmt>
      <IndivRcvdGreaterThan100KCnt>52</IndivRcvdGreaterThan100KCnt>
      <FormerOfcrEmployeesListedInd>0</FormerOfcrEmployeesListedInd>
      <TotalCompGreaterThan150KInd>1</TotalCompGreaterThan150KInd>
      <CompensationFromOtherSrcsInd>0</CompensationFromOtherSrcsInd>
      <ContractorCompensationGrp>
        <ContractorName>
          <BusinessName>
            <BusinessNameLine1Txt>Biz Niche LLC</BusinessNameLine1Txt>
          </BusinessName>
        </ContractorName>
        <ContractorAddress>
          <USAddress>
            <AddressLine1Txt>16100 N Greenway-Hayden Loop Ste</AddressLine1Txt>
            <CityNm>Scottsdale</CityNm>
            <StateAbbreviationCd>AZ</StateAbbreviationCd>
            <ZIPCd>85260</ZIPCd>
          </USAddress>
        </ContractorAddress>
        <ServicesDesc>Website design services</ServicesDesc>
        <CompensationAmt>255908</CompensationAmt>
      </ContractorCompensationGrp>
      <CntrctRcvdGreaterThan100KCnt>1</CntrctRcvdGreaterThan100KCnt>
      <AllOtherContributionsAmt>21771790</AllOtherContributionsAmt>
      <NoncashContributionsAmt>954366</NoncashContributionsAmt>
      <TotalContributionsAmt>21771790</TotalContributionsAmt>
      <ProgramServiceRevenueGrp>
        <Desc>Court-awarded attorney fees</Desc>
        <BusinessCd>541100</BusinessCd>
        <TotalRevenueColumnAmt>1128139</TotalRevenueColumnAmt>
        <RelatedOrExemptFuncIncomeAmt>1128139</RelatedOrExemptFuncIncomeAmt>
      </ProgramServiceRevenueGrp>
      <TotalProgramServiceRevenueAmt>1128139</TotalProgramServiceRevenueAmt>
      <InvestmentIncomeGrp>
        <TotalRevenueColumnAmt>1646192</TotalRevenueColumnAmt>
        <ExclusionAmt>1646192</ExclusionAmt>
      </InvestmentIncomeGrp>
      <GrossAmountSalesAssetsGrp>
        <SecuritiesAmt>16386980</SecuritiesAmt>
        <OtherAmt>3628286</OtherAmt>
      </GrossAmountSalesAssetsGrp>
      <LessCostOthBasisSalesExpnssGrp>
        <SecuritiesAmt>16700270</SecuritiesAmt>
        <OtherAmt>2823799</OtherAmt>
      </LessCostOthBasisSalesExpnssGrp>
      <GainOrLossGrp>
        <SecuritiesAmt>-313290</SecuritiesAmt>
        <OtherAmt>804487</OtherAmt>
      </GainOrLossGrp>
      <NetGainOrLossInvestmentsGrp>
        <TotalRevenueColumnAmt>491197</TotalRevenueColumnAmt>
        <ExclusionAmt>491197</ExclusionAmt>
      </NetGainOrLossInvestmentsGrp>
      <OtherRevenueMiscGrp>
        <Desc>Other income</Desc>
        <BusinessCd>900099</BusinessCd>
        <TotalRevenueColumnAmt>32006</TotalRevenueColumnAmt>
        <ExclusionAmt>32006</ExclusionAmt>
      </OtherRevenueMiscGrp>
      <OtherRevenueTotalAmt>32006</OtherRevenueTotalAmt>
      <TotalRevenueGrp>
        <TotalRevenueColumnAmt>25069324</TotalRevenueColumnAmt>
        <RelatedOrExemptFuncIncomeAmt>1128139</RelatedOrExemptFuncIncomeAmt>
        <UnrelatedBusinessRevenueAmt>0</UnrelatedBusinessRevenueAmt>
        <ExclusionAmt>2169395</ExclusionAmt>
      </TotalRevenueGrp>
      <GrantsToDomesticOrgsGrp>
        <TotalAmt>120000</TotalAmt>
        <ProgramServicesAmt>120000</ProgramServicesAmt>
      </GrantsToDomesticOrgsGrp>
      <CompCurrentOfcrDirectorsGrp>
        <TotalAmt>1799430</TotalAmt>
        <ProgramServicesAmt>1499507</ProgramServicesAmt>
        <ManagementAndGeneralAmt>202717</ManagementAndGeneralAmt>
        <FundraisingAmt>97206</FundraisingAmt>
      </CompCurrentOfcrDirectorsGrp>
      <OtherSalariesAndWagesGrp>
        <TotalAmt>12349932</TotalAmt>
        <ProgramServicesAmt>10887897</ProgramServicesAmt>
        <ManagementAndGeneralAmt>794885</ManagementAndGeneralAmt>
        <FundraisingAmt>667150</FundraisingAmt>
      </OtherSalariesAndWagesGrp>
      <PensionPlanContributionsGrp>
        <TotalAmt>889161</TotalAmt>
        <ProgramServicesAmt>654275</ProgramServicesAmt>
        <ManagementAndGeneralAmt>149457</ManagementAndGeneralAmt>
        <FundraisingAmt>85429</FundraisingAmt>
      </PensionPlanContributionsGrp>
      <OtherEmployeeBenefitsGrp>
        <TotalAmt>1639219</TotalAmt>
        <ProgramServicesAmt>1229839</ProgramServicesAmt>
        <ManagementAndGeneralAmt>262087</ManagementAndGeneralAmt>
        <FundraisingAmt>147293</FundraisingAmt>
      </OtherEmployeeBenefitsGrp>
      <PayrollTaxesGrp>
        <TotalAmt>975336</TotalAmt>
        <ProgramServicesAmt>748026</ProgramServicesAmt>
        <ManagementAndGeneralAmt>131276</ManagementAndGeneralAmt>
        <FundraisingAmt>96034</FundraisingAmt>
      </PayrollTaxesGrp>
      <FeesForServicesLegalGrp>
        <TotalAmt>11611</TotalAmt>
        <ManagementAndGeneralAmt>11611</ManagementAndGeneralAmt>
      </FeesForServicesLegalGrp>
      <FeesForServicesAccountingGrp>
        <TotalAmt>56671</TotalAmt>
        <ManagementAndGeneralAmt>56671</ManagementAndGeneralAmt>
      </FeesForServicesAccountingGrp>
      <FeesForSrvcInvstMgmntFeesGrp>
        <TotalAmt>174932</TotalAmt>
        <ManagementAndGeneralAmt>174932</ManagementAndGeneralAmt>
      </FeesForSrvcInvstMgmntFeesGrp>
      <FeesForServicesOtherGrp>
        <TotalAmt>2219964</TotalAmt>
        <ProgramServicesAmt>2037025</ProgramServicesAmt>
        <ManagementAndGeneralAmt>120533</ManagementAndGeneralAmt>
        <FundraisingAmt>62406</FundraisingAmt>
      </FeesForServicesOtherGrp>
      <OfficeExpensesGrp>
        <TotalAmt>1504257</TotalAmt>
        <ProgramServicesAmt>709434</ProgramServicesAmt>
        <ManagementAndGeneralAmt>300407</ManagementAndGeneralAmt>
        <FundraisingAmt>494416</FundraisingAmt>
      </OfficeExpensesGrp>
      <InformationTechnologyGrp>
        <TotalAmt>449870</TotalAmt>
        <ProgramServicesAmt>195155</ProgramServicesAmt>
        <ManagementAndGeneralAmt>93937</ManagementAndGeneralAmt>
        <FundraisingAmt>160778</FundraisingAmt>
      </InformationTechnologyGrp>
      <OccupancyGrp>
        <TotalAmt>772352</TotalAmt>
        <ProgramServicesAmt>643640</ProgramServicesAmt>
        <ManagementAndGeneralAmt>87003</ManagementAndGeneralAmt>
        <FundraisingAmt>41709</FundraisingAmt>
      </OccupancyGrp>
      <TravelGrp>
        <TotalAmt>1774095</TotalAmt>
        <ProgramServicesAmt>1433079</ProgramServicesAmt>
        <ManagementAndGeneralAmt>188953</ManagementAndGeneralAmt>
        <FundraisingAmt>152063</FundraisingAmt>
      </TravelGrp>
      <DepreciationDepletionGrp>
        <TotalAmt>247377</TotalAmt>
        <ProgramServicesAmt>203606</ProgramServicesAmt>
        <ManagementAndGeneralAmt>30853</ManagementAndGeneralAmt>
        <FundraisingAmt>12918</FundraisingAmt>
      </DepreciationDepletionGrp>
      <InsuranceGrp>
        <TotalAmt>106613</TotalAmt>
        <ProgramServicesAmt>89007</ProgramServicesAmt>
        <ManagementAndGeneralAmt>11957</ManagementAndGeneralAmt>
        <FundraisingAmt>5649</FundraisingAmt>
      </InsuranceGrp>
      <OtherExpensesGrp>
        <Desc>Registrations/Fees</Desc>
        <TotalAmt>287194</TotalAmt>
        <ProgramServicesAmt>250678</ProgramServicesAmt>
        <ManagementAndGeneralAmt>29481</ManagementAndGeneralAmt>
        <FundraisingAmt>7035</FundraisingAmt>
      </OtherExpensesGrp>
      <OtherExpensesGrp>
        <Desc>Library and research</Desc>
        <TotalAmt>175092</TotalAmt>
        <ProgramServicesAmt>173792</ProgramServicesAmt>
        <ManagementAndGeneralAmt>1300</ManagementAndGeneralAmt>
      </OtherExpensesGrp>
      <OtherExpensesGrp>
        <Desc>Miscellaneous</Desc>
        <TotalAmt>9051</TotalAmt>
        <ProgramServicesAmt>3210</ProgramServicesAmt>
        <ManagementAndGeneralAmt>5637</ManagementAndGeneralAmt>
        <FundraisingAmt>204</FundraisingAmt>
      </OtherExpensesGrp>
      <TotalFunctionalExpensesGrp>
        <TotalAmt>25562157</TotalAmt>
        <ProgramServicesAmt>20878170</ProgramServicesAmt>
        <ManagementAndGeneralAmt>2653697</ManagementAndGeneralAmt>
        <FundraisingAmt>2030290</FundraisingAmt>
      </TotalFunctionalExpensesGrp>
      <CashNonInterestBearingGrp>
        <BOYAmt>1636621</BOYAmt>
        <EOYAmt>4301308</EOYAmt>
      </CashNonInterestBearingGrp>
      <SavingsAndTempCashInvstGrp>
        <BOYAmt>3058</BOYAmt>
      </SavingsAndTempCashInvstGrp>
      <PledgesAndGrantsReceivableGrp>
        <BOYAmt>3178685</BOYAmt>
        <EOYAmt>845639</EOYAmt>
      </PledgesAndGrantsReceivableGrp>
      <PrepaidExpensesDefrdChargesGrp>
        <BOYAmt>273872</BOYAmt>
        <EOYAmt>299661</EOYAmt>
      </PrepaidExpensesDefrdChargesGrp>
      <LandBldgEquipCostOrOtherBssAmt>2546194</LandBldgEquipCostOrOtherBssAmt>
      <LandBldgEquipAccumDeprecAmt>1770181</LandBldgEquipAccumDeprecAmt>
      <LandBldgEquipBasisNetGrp>
        <BOYAmt>3187384</BOYAmt>
        <EOYAmt>776013</EOYAmt>
      </LandBldgEquipBasisNetGrp>
      <InvestmentsPubTradedSecGrp>
        <BOYAmt>60368115</BOYAmt>
        <EOYAmt>69510473</EOYAmt>
      </InvestmentsPubTradedSecGrp>
      <InvestmentsOtherSecuritiesGrp>
        <BOYAmt>4601792</BOYAmt>
        <EOYAmt>4557666</EOYAmt>
      </InvestmentsOtherSecuritiesGrp>
      <OtherAssetsTotalGrp>
        <BOYAmt>3526652</BOYAmt>
        <EOYAmt>4929500</EOYAmt>
      </OtherAssetsTotalGrp>
      <TotalAssetsGrp>
        <BOYAmt>76776179</BOYAmt>
        <EOYAmt>85220260</EOYAmt>
      </TotalAssetsGrp>
      <AccountsPayableAccrExpnssGrp>
        <BOYAmt>1217732</BOYAmt>
        <EOYAmt>1454478</EOYAmt>
      </AccountsPayableAccrExpnssGrp>
      <OtherLiabilitiesGrp>
        <BOYAmt>3641959</BOYAmt>
        <EOYAmt>5721326</EOYAmt>
      </OtherLiabilitiesGrp>
      <TotalLiabilitiesGrp>
        <BOYAmt>4859691</BOYAmt>
        <EOYAmt>7175804</EOYAmt>
      </TotalLiabilitiesGrp>
      <OrganizationFollowsFASB117Ind>X</OrganizationFollowsFASB117Ind>
      <NoDonorRestrictionNetAssetsGrp>
        <BOYAmt>66122435</BOYAmt>
        <EOYAmt>74096101</EOYAmt>
      </NoDonorRestrictionNetAssetsGrp>
      <DonorRestrictionNetAssetsGrp>
        <BOYAmt>5794053</BOYAmt>
        <EOYAmt>3948355</EOYAmt>
      </DonorRestrictionNetAssetsGrp>
      <TotalNetAssetsFundBalanceGrp>
        <BOYAmt>71916488</BOYAmt>
        <EOYAmt>78044456</EOYAmt>
      </TotalNetAssetsFundBalanceGrp>
      <TotLiabNetAssetsFundBalanceGrp>
        <BOYAmt>76776179</BOYAmt>
        <EOYAmt>85220260</EOYAmt>
      </TotLiabNetAssetsFundBalanceGrp>
      <InfoInScheduleOPartXIInd>X</InfoInScheduleOPartXIInd>
      <ReconcilationRevenueExpnssAmt>-492833</ReconcilationRevenueExpnssAmt>
      <NetUnrlzdGainsLossesInvstAmt>6393983</NetUnrlzdGainsLossesInvstAmt>
      <OtherChangesInNetAssetsAmt>226818</OtherChangesInNetAssetsAmt>
      <InfoInScheduleOPartXIIInd>X</InfoInScheduleOPartXIIInd>
      <MethodOfAccountingAccrualInd>X</MethodOfAccountingAccrualInd>
      <AccountantCompileOrReviewInd>0</AccountantCompileOrReviewInd>
      <FSAuditedInd>1</FSAuditedInd>
      <FSAuditedBasisGrp>
        <SeparateBasisFinclStmtInd>X</SeparateBasisFinclStmtInd>
      </FSAuditedBasisGrp>
      <AuditCommitteeInd>1</AuditCommitteeInd>
      <FederalGrantAuditRequiredInd>0</FederalGrantAuditRequiredInd>
    </IRS990>
    <IRS990ScheduleA documentId="RetDoc1039100001">
      <PublicOrganization170Ind>X</PublicOrganization170Ind>
      <GiftsGrantsContriRcvd170Grp>
        <CurrentTaxYearMinus4YearsAmt>13608144</CurrentTaxYearMinus4YearsAmt>
        <CurrentTaxYearMinus3YearsAmt>13762161</CurrentTaxYearMinus3YearsAmt>
        <CurrentTaxYearMinus2YearsAmt>16892254</CurrentTaxYearMinus2YearsAmt>
        <CurrentTaxYearMinus1YearAmt>26374951</CurrentTaxYearMinus1YearAmt>
        <CurrentTaxYearAmt>21771790</CurrentTaxYearAmt>
        <TotalAmt>92409300</TotalAmt>
      </GiftsGrantsContriRcvd170Grp>
      <TotalCalendarYear170Grp>
        <CurrentTaxYearMinus4YearsAmt>13608144</CurrentTaxYearMinus4YearsAmt>
        <CurrentTaxYearMinus3YearsAmt>13762161</CurrentTaxYearMinus3YearsAmt>
        <CurrentTaxYearMinus2YearsAmt>16892254</CurrentTaxYearMinus2YearsAmt>
        <CurrentTaxYearMinus1YearAmt>26374951</CurrentTaxYearMinus1YearAmt>
        <CurrentTaxYearAmt>21771790</CurrentTaxYearAmt>
        <TotalAmt>92409300</TotalAmt>
      </TotalCalendarYear170Grp>
      <SubstantialContributorsTotAmt>4134237</SubstantialContributorsTotAmt>
      <PublicSupportTotal170Amt>88275063</PublicSupportTotal170Amt>
      <GrossInvestmentIncome170Grp>
        <CurrentTaxYearMinus4YearsAmt>1198141</CurrentTaxYearMinus4YearsAmt>
        <CurrentTaxYearMinus3YearsAmt>1257015</CurrentTaxYearMinus3YearsAmt>
        <CurrentTaxYearMinus2YearsAmt>692541</CurrentTaxYearMinus2YearsAmt>
        <CurrentTaxYearMinus1YearAmt>1373866</CurrentTaxYearMinus1YearAmt>
        <CurrentTaxYearAmt>1646192</CurrentTaxYearAmt>
        <TotalAmt>6167755</TotalAmt>
      </GrossInvestmentIncome170Grp>
      <OtherIncome170Grp>
        <CurrentTaxYearMinus4YearsAmt>32771</CurrentTaxYearMinus4YearsAmt>
        <CurrentTaxYearMinus3YearsAmt>155488</CurrentTaxYearMinus3YearsAmt>
        <CurrentTaxYearMinus2YearsAmt>299957</CurrentTaxYearMinus2YearsAmt>
        <CurrentTaxYearMinus1YearAmt>111055</CurrentTaxYearMinus1YearAmt>
        <CurrentTaxYearAmt>32006</CurrentTaxYearAmt>
        <TotalAmt>631277</TotalAmt>
      </OtherIncome170Grp>
      <TotalSupportAmt>99208332</TotalSupportAmt>
      <GrossReceiptsRltdActivitiesAmt>2700516</GrossReceiptsRltdActivitiesAmt>
      <PublicSupportCY170Pct>0.88980</PublicSupportCY170Pct>
      <PublicSupportPY170Pct>0.76980</PublicSupportPY170Pct>
      <ThirtyThrPctSuprtTestsCY170Ind>X</ThirtyThrPctSuprtTestsCY170Ind>
      <Form990ScheduleAPartVIGrp>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Schedule A, Part II, Line 10, Explanation of Other Income:</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>Other Income - 2018 Amount: $ 32,771. 2019 Amount: $ 155,488. 2020 Amount: $ 299,957. 2021 Amount: $ 111,055. 2022 Amount: $ 32,006.</ExplanationTxt>
      </Form990ScheduleAPartVIGrp>
    </IRS990ScheduleA>
    <IRS990ScheduleB documentId="RetDoc1234500001">
      <ContributorInformationGrp>
        <ContributorNum>RESTRICTED</ContributorNum>
        <ContributorBusinessName>
          <BusinessNameLine1>RESTRICTED</BusinessNameLine1>
        </ContributorBusinessName>
        <ContributorUSAddress>
          <AddressLine1>RESTRICTED</AddressLine1>
          <AddressLine2>RESTRICTED</AddressLine2>
          <City>RESTRICTED</City>
          <State>RESTRICTED</State>
          <ZIPCode>RESTRICTED</ZIPCode>
        </ContributorUSAddress>
        <TotalContributionsAmt>RESTRICTED</TotalContributionsAmt>
      </ContributorInformationGrp>
    </IRS990ScheduleB>
    <IRS990ScheduleC documentId="RetDoc1039600001">
      <TotalGrassrootsLobbyingGrp>
        <FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt>0</FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt>
      </TotalGrassrootsLobbyingGrp>
      <TotalDirectLobbyingGrp>
        <FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt>23076</FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt>
      </TotalDirectLobbyingGrp>
      <TotalLobbyingExpendGrp>
        <FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt>23076</FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt>
      </TotalLobbyingExpendGrp>
      <OtherExemptPurposeExpendGrp>
        <FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt>25539081</FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt>
      </OtherExemptPurposeExpendGrp>
      <TotalExemptPurposeExpendGrp>
        <FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt>25562157</FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt>
      </TotalExemptPurposeExpendGrp>
      <LobbyingNontaxableAmountGrp>
        <FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt>1000000</FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt>
      </LobbyingNontaxableAmountGrp>
      <GrassrootsNontaxableGrp>
        <FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt>250000</FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt>
      </GrassrootsNontaxableGrp>
      <TotLbbyngGrassrootMnsNonTxGrp>
        <FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt>0</FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt>
      </TotLbbyngGrassrootMnsNonTxGrp>
      <TotLbbyExpendMnsLbbyngNonTxGrp>
        <FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt>0</FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt>
      </TotLbbyExpendMnsLbbyngNonTxGrp>
      <AvgLobbyingNontaxableAmountGrp>
        <CurrentYearMinus3Amt>973834</CurrentYearMinus3Amt>
        <CurrentYearMinus2Amt>1000000</CurrentYearMinus2Amt>
        <CurrentYearMinus1Amt>1000000</CurrentYearMinus1Amt>
        <CurrentYearAmt>1000000</CurrentYearAmt>
        <TotalAmt>3973834</TotalAmt>
      </AvgLobbyingNontaxableAmountGrp>
      <LobbyingCeilingAmt>5960751</LobbyingCeilingAmt>
      <AvgTotalLobbyingExpendGrp>
        <CurrentYearMinus3Amt>143036</CurrentYearMinus3Amt>
        <CurrentYearMinus2Amt>79090</CurrentYearMinus2Amt>
        <CurrentYearMinus1Amt>384173</CurrentYearMinus1Amt>
        <CurrentYearAmt>23076</CurrentYearAmt>
        <TotalAmt>629375</TotalAmt>
      </AvgTotalLobbyingExpendGrp>
      <AvgGrassrootsNontaxableGrp>
        <CurrentYearMinus3Amt>243459</CurrentYearMinus3Amt>
        <CurrentYearMinus2Amt>250000</CurrentYearMinus2Amt>
        <CurrentYearMinus1Amt>250000</CurrentYearMinus1Amt>
        <CurrentYearAmt>250000</CurrentYearAmt>
        <TotalAmt>993459</TotalAmt>
      </AvgGrassrootsNontaxableGrp>
      <GrassrootsCeilingAmt>1490189</GrassrootsCeilingAmt>
    </IRS990ScheduleC>
    <IRS990ScheduleD documentId="RetDoc1040000001">
      <CYEndwmtFundGrp>
        <BeginningYearBalanceAmt>61204043</BeginningYearBalanceAmt>
        <ContributionsAmt>8031016</ContributionsAmt>
        <InvestmentEarningsOrLossesAmt>7587380</InvestmentEarningsOrLossesAmt>
        <OtherExpendituresAmt>6478296</OtherExpendituresAmt>
        <AdministrativeExpensesAmt>159027</AdministrativeExpensesAmt>
        <EndYearBalanceAmt>70185116</EndYearBalanceAmt>
      </CYEndwmtFundGrp>
      <CYMinus1YrEndwmtFundGrp>
        <BeginningYearBalanceAmt>67085450</BeginningYearBalanceAmt>
        <ContributionsAmt>4482861</ContributionsAmt>
        <InvestmentEarningsOrLossesAmt>-8705901</InvestmentEarningsOrLossesAmt>
        <OtherExpendituresAmt>1495905</OtherExpendituresAmt>
        <AdministrativeExpensesAmt>162462</AdministrativeExpensesAmt>
        <EndYearBalanceAmt>61204043</EndYearBalanceAmt>
      </CYMinus1YrEndwmtFundGrp>
      <CYMinus2YrEndwmtFundGrp>
        <BeginningYearBalanceAmt>53198337</BeginningYearBalanceAmt>
        <ContributionsAmt>1411631</ContributionsAmt>
        <InvestmentEarningsOrLossesAmt>14233204</InvestmentEarningsOrLossesAmt>
        <OtherExpendituresAmt>1613764</OtherExpendituresAmt>
        <AdministrativeExpensesAmt>143958</AdministrativeExpensesAmt>
        <EndYearBalanceAmt>67085450</EndYearBalanceAmt>
      </CYMinus2YrEndwmtFundGrp>
      <CYMinus3YrEndwmtFundGrp>
        <BeginningYearBalanceAmt>54108051</BeginningYearBalanceAmt>
        <ContributionsAmt>3037510</ContributionsAmt>
        <InvestmentEarningsOrLossesAmt>1073612</InvestmentEarningsOrLossesAmt>
        <OtherExpendituresAmt>4889523</OtherExpendituresAmt>
        <AdministrativeExpensesAmt>131313</AdministrativeExpensesAmt>
        <EndYearBalanceAmt>53198337</EndYearBalanceAmt>
      </CYMinus3YrEndwmtFundGrp>
      <CYMinus4YrEndwmtFundGrp>
        <BeginningYearBalanceAmt>46792797</BeginningYearBalanceAmt>
        <ContributionsAmt>8222507</ContributionsAmt>
        <InvestmentEarningsOrLossesAmt>3960108</InvestmentEarningsOrLossesAmt>
        <OtherExpendituresAmt>4737887</OtherExpendituresAmt>
        <AdministrativeExpensesAmt>129474</AdministrativeExpensesAmt>
        <EndYearBalanceAmt>54108051</EndYearBalanceAmt>
      </CYMinus4YrEndwmtFundGrp>
      <BoardDesignatedBalanceEOYPct>0.97800</BoardDesignatedBalanceEOYPct>
      <PrmnntEndowmentBalanceEOYPct>0.02200</PrmnntEndowmentBalanceEOYPct>
      <EndowmentsHeldUnrelatedOrgInd>0</EndowmentsHeldUnrelatedOrgInd>
      <EndowmentsHeldRelatedOrgInd>0</EndowmentsHeldRelatedOrgInd>
      <LeaseholdImprovementsGrp>
        <OtherCostOrOtherBasisAmt>1666307</OtherCostOrOtherBasisAmt>
        <DepreciationAmt>1131288</DepreciationAmt>
        <BookValueAmt>535019</BookValueAmt>
      </LeaseholdImprovementsGrp>
      <EquipmentGrp>
        <OtherCostOrOtherBasisAmt>879887</OtherCostOrOtherBasisAmt>
        <DepreciationAmt>638893</DepreciationAmt>
        <BookValueAmt>240994</BookValueAmt>
      </EquipmentGrp>
      <TotalBookValueLandBuildingsAmt>776013</TotalBookValueLandBuildingsAmt>
      <OtherSecuritiesGrp>
        <Desc>Real estate investment trusts</Desc>
        <BookValueAmt>1441934</BookValueAmt>
        <MethodValuationCd>F</MethodValuationCd>
      </OtherSecuritiesGrp>
      <OtherSecuritiesGrp>
        <Desc>Hedge funds</Desc>
        <BookValueAmt>3115732</BookValueAmt>
        <MethodValuationCd>F</MethodValuationCd>
      </OtherSecuritiesGrp>
      <TotalBookValueSecuritiesAmt>4557666</TotalBookValueSecuritiesAmt>
      <OtherAssetsOrgGrp>
        <Desc>Charitable remainder trusts receivable</Desc>
        <BookValueAmt>2872777</BookValueAmt>
      </OtherAssetsOrgGrp>
      <OtherAssetsOrgGrp>
        <Desc>Deposits</Desc>
        <BookValueAmt>99346</BookValueAmt>
      </OtherAssetsOrgGrp>
      <OtherAssetsOrgGrp>
        <Desc>Right-of-use assets - operating leases</Desc>
        <BookValueAmt>1957377</BookValueAmt>
      </OtherAssetsOrgGrp>
      <TotalBookValueOtherAssetsAmt>4929500</TotalBookValueOtherAssetsAmt>
      <OtherLiabilitiesOrgGrp>
        <Desc>Charitable gift annuities</Desc>
        <Amt>3437469</Amt>
      </OtherLiabilitiesOrgGrp>
      <OtherLiabilitiesOrgGrp>
        <Desc>Lease liabilities - operating leases</Desc>
        <Amt>2283857</Amt>
      </OtherLiabilitiesOrgGrp>
      <TotalLiabilityAmt>5721326</TotalLiabilityAmt>
      <FootnoteTextInd>X</FootnoteTextInd>
      <TotalRevEtcAuditedFinclStmtAmt>31544277</TotalRevEtcAuditedFinclStmtAmt>
      <NetUnrealizedGainsInvstAmt>6393983</NetUnrealizedGainsInvstAmt>
      <DonatedServicesAndUseFcltsAmt>8900</DonatedServicesAndUseFcltsAmt>
      <OtherRevenueAmt>226818</OtherRevenueAmt>
      <RevenueNotReportedAmt>6629701</RevenueNotReportedAmt>
      <RevenueSubtotalAmt>24914576</RevenueSubtotalAmt>
      <InvestmentExpensesNotIncldAmt>154748</InvestmentExpensesNotIncldAmt>
      <RevenueNotReportedFinclStmtAmt>154748</RevenueNotReportedFinclStmtAmt>
      <TotalRevenuePerForm990Amt>25069324</TotalRevenuePerForm990Amt>
      <TotExpnsEtcAuditedFinclStmtAmt>25416309</TotExpnsEtcAuditedFinclStmtAmt>
      <DonatedServicesUseFcltsAmt>8900</DonatedServicesUseFcltsAmt>
      <ExpensesNotReportedAmt>8900</ExpensesNotReportedAmt>
      <ExpensesSubtotalAmt>25407409</ExpensesSubtotalAmt>
      <InvestmentExpensesNotIncld2Amt>154748</InvestmentExpensesNotIncld2Amt>
      <ExpensesNotRptFinclStmtAmt>154748</ExpensesNotRptFinclStmtAmt>
      <TotalExpensesPerForm990Amt>25562157</TotalExpensesPerForm990Amt>
      <SupplementalInformationDetail>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Part V, Line 4:</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>The Organization's endowments include both donor-restricted endowment funds and funds designated by the Board of Trustees to function as endowments. Donor-restricted endowment funds that are perpetual in nature consist of one endowment fund to be invested in perpetuity with gains and losses. Interest and dividends are to be used for operating or other purposes as designated by the Board of Trustees. Board quasi-endowments have been designated to provide annual income that is predictable and reliable to assure the ability of the Organization to meet long-term professional obligations inherent in the nature of its litigation services.</ExplanationTxt>
      </SupplementalInformationDetail>
      <SupplementalInformationDetail>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Part X, Line 2:</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>Management evaluated the Organization's tax positions and has concluded that the Organization has taken no uncertain tax positions that require either recognition or disclosure in the accompanying consolidated financial statements.</ExplanationTxt>
      </SupplementalInformationDetail>
      <SupplementalInformationDetail>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Part XI, Line 2d - Other Adjustments:</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>Change in value of split-interest agreements 226,818.</ExplanationTxt>
      </SupplementalInformationDetail>
    </IRS990ScheduleD>
    <IRS990ScheduleI documentId="RetDoc1041900001">
      <GrantRecordsMaintainedInd>1</GrantRecordsMaintainedInd>
      <RecipientTable>
        <RecipientBusinessName>
          <BusinessNameLine1Txt>The John Locke Foundation Inc</BusinessNameLine1Txt>
        </RecipientBusinessName>
        <USAddress>
          <AddressLine1Txt>4800 Six Forks Rd Suite 220</AddressLine1Txt>
          <CityNm>Raleigh</CityNm>
          <StateAbbreviationCd>NC</StateAbbreviationCd>
          <ZIPCd>27609</ZIPCd>
        </USAddress>
        <RecipientEIN>561656943</RecipientEIN>
        <IRCSectionDesc>501(c)(3)</IRCSectionDesc>
        <CashGrantAmt>15000</CashGrantAmt>
        <NonCashAssistanceAmt>0</NonCashAssistanceAmt>
        <PurposeOfGrantTxt>Program Support</PurposeOfGrantTxt>
      </RecipientTable>
      <RecipientTable>
        <RecipientBusinessName>
          <BusinessNameLine1Txt>Iowans for Tax Relief Foundation</BusinessNameLine1Txt>
        </RecipientBusinessName>
        <USAddress>
          <AddressLine1Txt>7601 Office Plaza Dr North Suite</AddressLine1Txt>
          <AddressLine2Txt>140</AddressLine2Txt>
          <CityNm>West Des Moines</CityNm>
          <StateAbbreviationCd>IA</StateAbbreviationCd>
          <ZIPCd>50266</ZIPCd>
        </USAddress>
        <RecipientEIN>421184154</RecipientEIN>
        <IRCSectionDesc>501(c)(3)</IRCSectionDesc>
        <CashGrantAmt>15000</CashGrantAmt>
        <NonCashAssistanceAmt>0</NonCashAssistanceAmt>
        <PurposeOfGrantTxt>Program Support</PurposeOfGrantTxt>
      </RecipientTable>
      <RecipientTable>
        <RecipientBusinessName>
          <BusinessNameLine1Txt>Frontier Institute Inc</BusinessNameLine1Txt>
        </RecipientBusinessName>
        <USAddress>
          <AddressLine1Txt>PO Box 5104</AddressLine1Txt>
          <CityNm>Helana</CityNm>
          <StateAbbreviationCd>MT</StateAbbreviationCd>
          <ZIPCd>59604</ZIPCd>
        </USAddress>
        <RecipientEIN>850998465</RecipientEIN>
        <IRCSectionDesc>501(c)(3)</IRCSectionDesc>
        <CashGrantAmt>15000</CashGrantAmt>
        <NonCashAssistanceAmt>0</NonCashAssistanceAmt>
        <PurposeOfGrantTxt>Program Support</PurposeOfGrantTxt>
      </RecipientTable>
      <RecipientTable>
        <RecipientBusinessName>
          <BusinessNameLine1Txt>Platte Institute for Economic Research Inc</BusinessNameLine1Txt>
        </RecipientBusinessName>
        <USAddress>
          <AddressLine1Txt>910 Pacific Street Suite 216</AddressLine1Txt>
          <CityNm>Omaha</CityNm>
          <StateAbbreviationCd>NE</StateAbbreviationCd>
          <ZIPCd>68106</ZIPCd>
        </USAddress>
        <RecipientEIN>208809060</RecipientEIN>
        <IRCSectionDesc>501(c)(3)</IRCSectionDesc>
        <CashGrantAmt>15000</CashGrantAmt>
        <NonCashAssistanceAmt>0</NonCashAssistanceAmt>
        <PurposeOfGrantTxt>Program Support</PurposeOfGrantTxt>
      </RecipientTable>
      <RecipientTable>
        <RecipientBusinessName>
          <BusinessNameLine1Txt>Pelican Institute for Public Policy</BusinessNameLine1Txt>
        </RecipientBusinessName>
        <USAddress>
          <AddressLine1Txt>400 Poydras St Suite 900</AddressLine1Txt>
          <CityNm>New Orleans</CityNm>
          <StateAbbreviationCd>LA</StateAbbreviationCd>
          <ZIPCd>70130</ZIPCd>
        </USAddress>
        <RecipientEIN>261704791</RecipientEIN>
        <IRCSectionDesc>501(c)(3)</IRCSectionDesc>
        <CashGrantAmt>15000</CashGrantAmt>
        <NonCashAssistanceAmt>0</NonCashAssistanceAmt>
        <PurposeOfGrantTxt>Program Support</PurposeOfGrantTxt>
      </RecipientTable>
      <RecipientTable>
        <RecipientBusinessName>
          <BusinessNameLine1Txt>Texas Public Policy Foundation</BusinessNameLine1Txt>
        </RecipientBusinessName>
        <USAddress>
          <AddressLine1Txt>901 Congress Avenue</AddressLine1Txt>
          <CityNm>Austin</CityNm>
          <StateAbbreviationCd>TX</StateAbbreviationCd>
          <ZIPCd>78701</ZIPCd>
        </USAddress>
        <RecipientEIN>742524057</RecipientEIN>
        <IRCSectionDesc>501(c)(3)</IRCSectionDesc>
        <CashGrantAmt>15000</CashGrantAmt>
        <NonCashAssistanceAmt>0</NonCashAssistanceAmt>
        <PurposeOfGrantTxt>Program Support</PurposeOfGrantTxt>
      </RecipientTable>
      <RecipientTable>
        <RecipientBusinessName>
          <BusinessNameLine1Txt>Mackinac Center for Public Policy</BusinessNameLine1Txt>
        </RecipientBusinessName>
        <USAddress>
          <AddressLine1Txt>140 West Main Street PO Box 568</AddressLine1Txt>
          <CityNm>Midland</CityNm>
          <StateAbbreviationCd>MI</StateAbbreviationCd>
          <ZIPCd>48640</ZIPCd>
        </USAddress>
        <RecipientEIN>382701547</RecipientEIN>
        <IRCSectionDesc>501(c)(3)</IRCSectionDesc>
        <CashGrantAmt>15000</CashGrantAmt>
        <NonCashAssistanceAmt>0</NonCashAssistanceAmt>
        <PurposeOfGrantTxt>Program Support</PurposeOfGrantTxt>
      </RecipientTable>
      <RecipientTable>
        <RecipientBusinessName>
          <BusinessNameLine1Txt>The James Madison Institute for Public Policy Studies</BusinessNameLine1Txt>
        </RecipientBusinessName>
        <USAddress>
          <AddressLine1Txt>JMI Headquarters The Columns 100</AddressLine1Txt>
          <AddressLine2Txt>North Duval Street</AddressLine2Txt>
          <CityNm>Tallahassee</CityNm>
          <StateAbbreviationCd>FL</StateAbbreviationCd>
          <ZIPCd>32301</ZIPCd>
        </USAddress>
        <RecipientEIN>592811908</RecipientEIN>
        <IRCSectionDesc>501(c)(3)</IRCSectionDesc>
        <CashGrantAmt>15000</CashGrantAmt>
        <NonCashAssistanceAmt>0</NonCashAssistanceAmt>
        <PurposeOfGrantTxt>Program Support</PurposeOfGrantTxt>
      </RecipientTable>
      <Total501c3OrgCnt>8</Total501c3OrgCnt>
      <TotalOtherOrgCnt>0</TotalOtherOrgCnt>
      <SupplementalInformationDetail>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Part I, Line 2:</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>The organization requires grantees grant reports through the year and the funds could only be used for education purposes.</ExplanationTxt>
      </SupplementalInformationDetail>
    </IRS990ScheduleI>
    <IRS990ScheduleJ documentId="RetDoc1042400001">
      <CompensationCommitteeInd>X</CompensationCommitteeInd>
      <IndependentConsultantInd>X</IndependentConsultantInd>
      <Form990OfOtherOrganizationsInd>X</Form990OfOtherOrganizationsInd>
      <WrittenEmploymentContractInd>X</WrittenEmploymentContractInd>
      <CompensationSurveyInd>X</CompensationSurveyInd>
      <BoardOrCommitteeApprovalInd>X</BoardOrCommitteeApprovalInd>
      <SeverancePaymentInd>0</SeverancePaymentInd>
      <SupplementalNonqualRtrPlanInd>0</SupplementalNonqualRtrPlanInd>
      <EquityBasedCompArrngmInd>0</EquityBasedCompArrngmInd>
      <CompBasedOnRevenueOfFlngOrgInd>0</CompBasedOnRevenueOfFlngOrgInd>
      <CompBsdOnRevRelatedOrgsInd>0</CompBsdOnRevRelatedOrgsInd>
      <CompBsdNetEarnsFlngOrgInd>0</CompBsdNetEarnsFlngOrgInd>
      <CompBsdNetEarnsRltdOrgsInd>0</CompBsdNetEarnsRltdOrgsInd>
      <AnyNonFixedPaymentsInd>0</AnyNonFixedPaymentsInd>
      <InitialContractExceptionInd>0</InitialContractExceptionInd>
      <RltdOrgOfficerTrstKeyEmplGrp>
        <PersonNm>Steven D Anderson</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>President and CEO</TitleTxt>
        <BaseCompensationFilingOrgAmt>501807</BaseCompensationFilingOrgAmt>
        <CompensationBasedOnRltdOrgsAmt>0</CompensationBasedOnRltdOrgsAmt>
        <BonusFilingOrganizationAmount>58286</BonusFilingOrganizationAmount>
        <BonusRelatedOrganizationsAmt>0</BonusRelatedOrganizationsAmt>
        <OtherCompensationFilingOrgAmt>0</OtherCompensationFilingOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>0</OtherCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>
        <DeferredCompensationFlngOrgAmt>66400</DeferredCompensationFlngOrgAmt>
        <DeferredCompRltdOrgsAmt>0</DeferredCompRltdOrgsAmt>
        <NontaxableBenefitsFilingOrgAmt>24264</NontaxableBenefitsFilingOrgAmt>
        <NontaxableBenefitsRltdOrgsAmt>0</NontaxableBenefitsRltdOrgsAmt>
        <TotalCompensationFilingOrgAmt>650757</TotalCompensationFilingOrgAmt>
        <TotalCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>0</TotalCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>
        <CompReportPrior990FilingOrgAmt>0</CompReportPrior990FilingOrgAmt>
        <CompReportPrior990RltdOrgsAmt>0</CompReportPrior990RltdOrgsAmt>
      </RltdOrgOfficerTrstKeyEmplGrp>
      <RltdOrgOfficerTrstKeyEmplGrp>
        <PersonNm>John M Groen</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Executive Vice President</TitleTxt>
        <BaseCompensationFilingOrgAmt>315234</BaseCompensationFilingOrgAmt>
        <CompensationBasedOnRltdOrgsAmt>0</CompensationBasedOnRltdOrgsAmt>
        <BonusFilingOrganizationAmount>0</BonusFilingOrganizationAmount>
        <BonusRelatedOrganizationsAmt>0</BonusRelatedOrganizationsAmt>
        <OtherCompensationFilingOrgAmt>0</OtherCompensationFilingOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>0</OtherCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>
        <DeferredCompensationFlngOrgAmt>47127</DeferredCompensationFlngOrgAmt>
        <DeferredCompRltdOrgsAmt>0</DeferredCompRltdOrgsAmt>
        <NontaxableBenefitsFilingOrgAmt>19443</NontaxableBenefitsFilingOrgAmt>
        <NontaxableBenefitsRltdOrgsAmt>0</NontaxableBenefitsRltdOrgsAmt>
        <TotalCompensationFilingOrgAmt>381804</TotalCompensationFilingOrgAmt>
        <TotalCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>0</TotalCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>
        <CompReportPrior990FilingOrgAmt>0</CompReportPrior990FilingOrgAmt>
        <CompReportPrior990RltdOrgsAmt>0</CompReportPrior990RltdOrgsAmt>
      </RltdOrgOfficerTrstKeyEmplGrp>
      <RltdOrgOfficerTrstKeyEmplGrp>
        <PersonNm>Todd F Gaziano</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Chief of Legal Policy &amp; Research</TitleTxt>
        <BaseCompensationFilingOrgAmt>271651</BaseCompensationFilingOrgAmt>
        <CompensationBasedOnRltdOrgsAmt>0</CompensationBasedOnRltdOrgsAmt>
        <BonusFilingOrganizationAmount>0</BonusFilingOrganizationAmount>
        <BonusRelatedOrganizationsAmt>0</BonusRelatedOrganizationsAmt>
        <OtherCompensationFilingOrgAmt>0</OtherCompensationFilingOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>0</OtherCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>
        <DeferredCompensationFlngOrgAmt>33611</DeferredCompensationFlngOrgAmt>
        <DeferredCompRltdOrgsAmt>0</DeferredCompRltdOrgsAmt>
        <NontaxableBenefitsFilingOrgAmt>17366</NontaxableBenefitsFilingOrgAmt>
        <NontaxableBenefitsRltdOrgsAmt>0</NontaxableBenefitsRltdOrgsAmt>
        <TotalCompensationFilingOrgAmt>322628</TotalCompensationFilingOrgAmt>
        <TotalCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>0</TotalCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>
        <CompReportPrior990FilingOrgAmt>0</CompReportPrior990FilingOrgAmt>
        <CompReportPrior990RltdOrgsAmt>0</CompReportPrior990RltdOrgsAmt>
      </RltdOrgOfficerTrstKeyEmplGrp>
      <RltdOrgOfficerTrstKeyEmplGrp>
        <PersonNm>Larry G Salzman</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Secretary and Director of Litigation</TitleTxt>
        <BaseCompensationFilingOrgAmt>231367</BaseCompensationFilingOrgAmt>
        <CompensationBasedOnRltdOrgsAmt>0</CompensationBasedOnRltdOrgsAmt>
        <BonusFilingOrganizationAmount>0</BonusFilingOrganizationAmount>
        <BonusRelatedOrganizationsAmt>0</BonusRelatedOrganizationsAmt>
        <OtherCompensationFilingOrgAmt>0</OtherCompensationFilingOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>0</OtherCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>
        <DeferredCompensationFlngOrgAmt>41097</DeferredCompensationFlngOrgAmt>
        <DeferredCompRltdOrgsAmt>0</DeferredCompRltdOrgsAmt>
        <NontaxableBenefitsFilingOrgAmt>24238</NontaxableBenefitsFilingOrgAmt>
        <NontaxableBenefitsRltdOrgsAmt>0</NontaxableBenefitsRltdOrgsAmt>
        <TotalCompensationFilingOrgAmt>296702</TotalCompensationFilingOrgAmt>
        <TotalCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>0</TotalCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>
        <CompReportPrior990FilingOrgAmt>0</CompReportPrior990FilingOrgAmt>
        <CompReportPrior990RltdOrgsAmt>0</CompReportPrior990RltdOrgsAmt>
      </RltdOrgOfficerTrstKeyEmplGrp>
      <RltdOrgOfficerTrstKeyEmplGrp>
        <PersonNm>Charles E Wilcox IV</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Treasurer and CFO/COO</TitleTxt>
        <BaseCompensationFilingOrgAmt>231844</BaseCompensationFilingOrgAmt>
        <CompensationBasedOnRltdOrgsAmt>0</CompensationBasedOnRltdOrgsAmt>
        <BonusFilingOrganizationAmount>8286</BonusFilingOrganizationAmount>
        <BonusRelatedOrganizationsAmt>0</BonusRelatedOrganizationsAmt>
        <OtherCompensationFilingOrgAmt>0</OtherCompensationFilingOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>0</OtherCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>
        <DeferredCompensationFlngOrgAmt>40303</DeferredCompensationFlngOrgAmt>
        <DeferredCompRltdOrgsAmt>0</DeferredCompRltdOrgsAmt>
        <NontaxableBenefitsFilingOrgAmt>13156</NontaxableBenefitsFilingOrgAmt>
        <NontaxableBenefitsRltdOrgsAmt>0</NontaxableBenefitsRltdOrgsAmt>
        <TotalCompensationFilingOrgAmt>293589</TotalCompensationFilingOrgAmt>
        <TotalCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>0</TotalCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>
        <CompReportPrior990FilingOrgAmt>0</CompReportPrior990FilingOrgAmt>
        <CompReportPrior990RltdOrgsAmt>0</CompReportPrior990RltdOrgsAmt>
      </RltdOrgOfficerTrstKeyEmplGrp>
      <RltdOrgOfficerTrstKeyEmplGrp>
        <PersonNm>James S Burling</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Vice President Legal Affair</TitleTxt>
        <BaseCompensationFilingOrgAmt>230251</BaseCompensationFilingOrgAmt>
        <CompensationBasedOnRltdOrgsAmt>0</CompensationBasedOnRltdOrgsAmt>
        <BonusFilingOrganizationAmount>0</BonusFilingOrganizationAmount>
        <BonusRelatedOrganizationsAmt>0</BonusRelatedOrganizationsAmt>
        <OtherCompensationFilingOrgAmt>0</OtherCompensationFilingOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>0</OtherCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>
        <DeferredCompensationFlngOrgAmt>30170</DeferredCompensationFlngOrgAmt>
        <DeferredCompRltdOrgsAmt>0</DeferredCompRltdOrgsAmt>
        <NontaxableBenefitsFilingOrgAmt>17474</NontaxableBenefitsFilingOrgAmt>
        <NontaxableBenefitsRltdOrgsAmt>0</NontaxableBenefitsRltdOrgsAmt>
        <TotalCompensationFilingOrgAmt>277895</TotalCompensationFilingOrgAmt>
        <TotalCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>0</TotalCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>
        <CompReportPrior990FilingOrgAmt>0</CompReportPrior990FilingOrgAmt>
        <CompReportPrior990RltdOrgsAmt>0</CompReportPrior990RltdOrgsAmt>
      </RltdOrgOfficerTrstKeyEmplGrp>
      <RltdOrgOfficerTrstKeyEmplGrp>
        <PersonNm>Steve Simpson</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Senior Attorney</TitleTxt>
        <BaseCompensationFilingOrgAmt>244467</BaseCompensationFilingOrgAmt>
        <CompensationBasedOnRltdOrgsAmt>0</CompensationBasedOnRltdOrgsAmt>
        <BonusFilingOrganizationAmount>0</BonusFilingOrganizationAmount>
        <BonusRelatedOrganizationsAmt>0</BonusRelatedOrganizationsAmt>
        <OtherCompensationFilingOrgAmt>0</OtherCompensationFilingOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>0</OtherCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>
        <DeferredCompensationFlngOrgAmt>20690</DeferredCompensationFlngOrgAmt>
        <DeferredCompRltdOrgsAmt>0</DeferredCompRltdOrgsAmt>
        <NontaxableBenefitsFilingOrgAmt>12329</NontaxableBenefitsFilingOrgAmt>
        <NontaxableBenefitsRltdOrgsAmt>0</NontaxableBenefitsRltdOrgsAmt>
        <TotalCompensationFilingOrgAmt>277486</TotalCompensationFilingOrgAmt>
        <TotalCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>0</TotalCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>
        <CompReportPrior990FilingOrgAmt>0</CompReportPrior990FilingOrgAmt>
        <CompReportPrior990RltdOrgsAmt>0</CompReportPrior990RltdOrgsAmt>
      </RltdOrgOfficerTrstKeyEmplGrp>
      <RltdOrgOfficerTrstKeyEmplGrp>
        <PersonNm>Damien Schiff</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Senior Attorney</TitleTxt>
        <BaseCompensationFilingOrgAmt>200008</BaseCompensationFilingOrgAmt>
        <CompensationBasedOnRltdOrgsAmt>0</CompensationBasedOnRltdOrgsAmt>
        <BonusFilingOrganizationAmount>19000</BonusFilingOrganizationAmount>
        <BonusRelatedOrganizationsAmt>0</BonusRelatedOrganizationsAmt>
        <OtherCompensationFilingOrgAmt>0</OtherCompensationFilingOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>0</OtherCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>
        <DeferredCompensationFlngOrgAmt>19128</DeferredCompensationFlngOrgAmt>
        <DeferredCompRltdOrgsAmt>0</DeferredCompRltdOrgsAmt>
        <NontaxableBenefitsFilingOrgAmt>22290</NontaxableBenefitsFilingOrgAmt>
        <NontaxableBenefitsRltdOrgsAmt>0</NontaxableBenefitsRltdOrgsAmt>
        <TotalCompensationFilingOrgAmt>260426</TotalCompensationFilingOrgAmt>
        <TotalCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>0</TotalCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>
        <CompReportPrior990FilingOrgAmt>0</CompReportPrior990FilingOrgAmt>
        <CompReportPrior990RltdOrgsAmt>0</CompReportPrior990RltdOrgsAmt>
      </RltdOrgOfficerTrstKeyEmplGrp>
      <RltdOrgOfficerTrstKeyEmplGrp>
        <PersonNm>Joshua Thompson</PersonNm>
        <TitleTxt>Dir.of Equality &amp; Opportunity Litiga</TitleTxt>
        <BaseCompensationFilingOrgAmt>206322</BaseCompensationFilingOrgAmt>
        <CompensationBasedOnRltdOrgsAmt>0</CompensationBasedOnRltdOrgsAmt>
        <BonusFilingOrganizationAmount>0</BonusFilingOrganizationAmount>
        <BonusRelatedOrganizationsAmt>0</BonusRelatedOrganizationsAmt>
        <OtherCompensationFilingOrgAmt>0</OtherCompensationFilingOrgAmt>
        <OtherCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>0</OtherCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>
        <DeferredCompensationFlngOrgAmt>28613</DeferredCompensationFlngOrgAmt>
        <DeferredCompRltdOrgsAmt>0</DeferredCompRltdOrgsAmt>
        <NontaxableBenefitsFilingOrgAmt>22305</NontaxableBenefitsFilingOrgAmt>
        <NontaxableBenefitsRltdOrgsAmt>0</NontaxableBenefitsRltdOrgsAmt>
        <TotalCompensationFilingOrgAmt>257240</TotalCompensationFilingOrgAmt>
        <TotalCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>0</TotalCompensationRltdOrgsAmt>
        <CompReportPrior990FilingOrgAmt>0</CompReportPrior990FilingOrgAmt>
        <CompReportPrior990RltdOrgsAmt>0</CompReportPrior990RltdOrgsAmt>
      </RltdOrgOfficerTrstKeyEmplGrp>
    </IRS990ScheduleJ>
    <IRS990ScheduleM documentId="RetDoc1042900001">
      <SecuritiesPubliclyTradedGrp>
        <NonCashCheckboxInd>X</NonCashCheckboxInd>
        <ContributionCnt>25</ContributionCnt>
        <NoncashContributionsRptF990Amt>954366</NoncashContributionsRptF990Amt>
        <MethodOfDeterminingRevenuesTxt>Fair Market Value</MethodOfDeterminingRevenuesTxt>
      </SecuritiesPubliclyTradedGrp>
      <AnyPropertyThatMustBeHeldInd>0</AnyPropertyThatMustBeHeldInd>
      <ReviewProcessUnusualNCGiftsInd>1</ReviewProcessUnusualNCGiftsInd>
      <ThirdPartiesUsedInd>0</ThirdPartiesUsedInd>
    </IRS990ScheduleM>
    <IRS990ScheduleO documentId="RetDoc1044400001">
      <SupplementalInformationDetail>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Form 990, Part III, Line 1, Description of Organization Mission:</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>Pacific Legal Foundation (PLF) litigates nationwide to secure all Americans' inalienable rights to live responsibly and productively in their pursuit of happiness. PLF combines strategic and principled litigation, communication, and research to achieve landmark court victories enforcing the Constitution's guarantee of individual liberty.</ExplanationTxt>
      </SupplementalInformationDetail>
      <SupplementalInformationDetail>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Form 990, Part III, Line 4a</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>PLF attorneys directly represented clients in the following cases furthering the Foundation's overarching mission to protect and enhance individual liberty. The cases further the goals of individual rights and liberty in the realms of property rights, separation of powers, equality under the law, and economic opportunity. In all cases, actions attributed to PLF were done by PLF attorneys properly admitted to each jurisdiction. Property Rights: A society cannot flourish and individuals cannot advance their private interests without individual rights to create and productively use property. PLF litigates to secure the right to the productive and ordinary use of land; prevent governments from taking property; fight unconstitutional or unlawful regulatory requirements; promote balance in environmental laws; and stop unreasonable searches and seizures. 835 Hinesburg Road LLC v. South Burlington, Vermont. 835 Hinesburg Road, LLC, is challenging a city's designation of a portion of its land as open space "Habitat Blocks." The ordinance that created the Habitat Blocks categorically classifies some of the owner's land as unbuildable, and the city rejected the owner's development proposal. Yet when the owner sued the city for a regulatory taking, the district court dismissed the case on the theory that the case is not ripe because the city retains discretion to approve some development in the future. PLF represents the owner on appeal to the Second Circuit to argue that federal courts should be as receptive to civil rights claims based on property ownership as they are to other civil rights claims. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Arabella Farm v. Naturaland Trust. PLF represents South Carolina landowner Ken Smith and others who comprise Arabella Farm to protect property owners from abusive Clean Water Act "citizen suits." These lawsuits, sometimes called "environmental ambulance chasing," are increasingly used by environmental groups and law firms to exact civil penalties and attorneys' fees from individuals and small businesses. The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals issued a decision to make it easier for these groups to sue property owners-even when the property owners have complied with enforcement orders by state governments-thus exposing them to secondary civil penalties and other liability. PLF filed a petition for writ of certiorari in the Supreme Court, seeking reversal of that decision. The petition was denied. PLF did not seek or recover fees. Ariyan v. Sewerage &amp; Water Board of New Orleans. The Ariyans secured a multi-million dollar just compensation award in state court but the government has delayed payment for several years. They sued, arguing that the Fifth Amendment entitles them to certain and timely just compensation. The courts denied them relief. PLF took over the case and filed a petition for rehearing en banc in the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, which was denied. PLF filed a petition for writ of certiorari, arguing that the Fifth Amendment Takings Clause is self-executing and a court ordered judgment is a secondary property interest that cannot be taken without just compensation. The petition was denied and the case is closed. PLF did not seek or recover fees. Benedetti v. County of Marin, California. Before they may build a family home on the rural property they have owned for years, the Benedetti family-brothers Arron and Arthur who inherited the estate of their father, Willie-must first agree that they will be "actively and directly engaged in agriculture and must record a restrictive covenant that they and all future owners of the home will be farmers or ranchers forever. The county's requirement, part of its local land use plan, places an unconstitutional condition on the Benedettis' liberty and property rights. PLF filed a lawsuit on their behalf in state court. Because litigation is ongoing, it is premature to seek fees. Bordelon v. Baldwin County, Alabama. PLF represents Mike Bordelon and Breezy Shores, LLC, who are developers who intended to build a three-story, 14-unit residential rental building. After obtaining the necessary permits and starting construction, the county bowed to community pressure and issued a Stop Work Order. The revocation of the building permit caused economic harm and destroyed the owner's reasonable investment-backed expectations, and the character of the government action differed little from a physical invasion. As such, the order caused a regulatory taking for which the county must pay just compensation. The developers won in the trial court and the county appealed. PLF looks to preserve their victory in the Eleventh Circuit. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Cedar Point Nursery v. Gould. Representing a California nursery and packing company, PLF sued to challenge a state regulation issued by the Agricultural Labor Relations Board that allows union organizers to access an employer's premises for the purpose of soliciting employees to join the union. PLF argues that this is an unconstitutional taking and further violates the Fourth Amendment's prohibition on unreasonable seizures. After adverse opinions in lower courts, PLF filed a petition for writ of certiorari, which was granted. Victory! The Supreme Court ruled 6-3 that the access regulation was a physical taking. The Court remanded to lower courts for further proceedings consistent with the ruling and awarded PLF $300 in costs. On remand, the district court entered judgment in favor of Cedar Point. PLF recovered $800,000 in attorneys' fees and costs. The case is closed. DiPietro v. Town of Bolton, Massachusetts. The Town of Bolton took Alan DiPietro's home, farm, and land worth at least $370,000 as payment for a debt of approximately $60,000. Bolton not only confiscated DiPietro's title and equity, it also thwarted his attempts to pay his debt and save his farm from foreclosure. Bolton's theft of DiPietro's home equity, above and beyond the amount of the debt, violated the state and federal constitutional prohibitions on takings of property without just compensation and imposition of excessive fines as well as the common law that forbids unjust enrichment. PLF represents DiPietro in a federal court challenge to the home equity theft. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. El Papel v. City of Seattle. PLF represents several Seattle landlords in a federal lawsuit challenging state and city rules that prohibit landlords from evicting tenants. The rules, adopted in response to the pandemic, violate landlords' rights to freely use and occupy their property. Governments shouldn't use overly broad emergency action to force landlords-or any businesses-to house non-paying or disruptive tenants against their will. There are other solutions that the government can leverage, such as rental assistance, that respect the rights of property owners while responding to the needs of tenants. The parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment. The magistrate recommended that PLF's motion be denied and PLF filed objections. The court ruled in favor of the city on grounds of mootness. PLF appealed to the Ninth Circuit. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Evans Creek LLC v. City of Reno. The City of Reno, Nevada, refused to annex Evans Creek's 1500-acre property, a necessary first step to development, with the result that the property owners are left without any practical productive use of the land. The trial court dismissed the case for failing to plead the three factors that currently govern regulatory takings cases under Penn Central Transp. Corp. v. City of New York (1978): (1) the economic impact of the regulation; (2) the extent of interference with the property owner's investment-backed expectations; and (3) the character of the government action. On behalf of Evans Creek, PLF filed a petition for writ of certiorari asking the Supreme Court to reconsider Penn Central and allow regulatory takings claims to move forward to the merits when regulations have substantially denied the use of the property. The petition was denied. PLF did not seek or recover fees.</ExplanationTxt>
      </SupplementalInformationDetail>
      <SupplementalInformationDetail>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Form 990, Part III, Line 4a</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>Fair v. Continental Resources. Kevin and Terry Fair fell behind on their property taxes after medical problems caused severe financial hardship. When they failed to pay $5,200 in taxes, interest, penalties, and costs by the deadline, Scotts Bluff County extinguished the Fairs' entire interest in their $60,000 home and conveyed it to an investor who paid the tax debt. Unlike other types of debt collection, the Fairs' foreclosed home was not sold after competitive bidding, leaving no opportunity for the Fairs to be paid for their equity from the proceeds remaining after paying the debt. Terry Fair passed away, and PLF represents Kevin Fair in a petition asking the Supreme Court to review the statutes authorizing home equity theft. The Court granted the petition, vacated the Nebraska Supreme Court decision, and remanded for reconsideration in light of PLF's victory in Tyler v. Hennepin County. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Fakhreddine v. Sabree. PLF represents Fadi Abi Fakhreddine and Old Joy Investment Co., Inc., in the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals, alleging that the government unconstitutionally took surplus equity when it foreclosed on two parcels of property and then gave them to the Detroit Land Bank. The land bank sold the properties for a substantial profit, all of which it kept. The former owners received nothing, losing all their invested equity without compensation. The Sixth Circuit agreed with PLF and on the basis of the decision in Hall v. Meisner (see below) reversed the district court's dismissal and remanded for further proceedings. The Sixth Circuit awarded PLF $505 in costs. PLF did not seek or recover fees. This case is closed. Financial Oversight and Management Board for Puerto Rico v. Cooperativa de Ahorro y Credito Abraham Rosa, et al. PLF represents more than two dozen property owners in Puerto Rico who obtained just compensation awards after the government took their property. When Puerto Rico declared bankruptcy in 2016, it sought to discharge the just compensation debts in the bankruptcy proceedings. The federal district court and First Circuit Court of Appeals refused to permit the discharge because the Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution requires just compensation after a taking. The government filed a petition for writ of certiorari and PLF defended the lower court decision on behalf of the just compensation claimants before the U.S. Supreme Court. As PLF advocated, the petition was denied, a victory for the property owners. PLF did not seek or recover fees. This case is closed. Flying Crown Subdivision v. Alaska Railroad Corporation. PLF represents a homeowners' association near Anchorage Alaska ion appeal in a dispute against the state-owned Alaska Railroad. For decades, many homeowners have used a nearby airstrip to fly and some homeowners purchased their homes specifically because of their proximity to the airstrip. The Railroad filed a Quiet Title Act case against the homeowners, alleging that they own an exclusive easement, and because a portion of the airstrip overlaps with a portion of the railroad easement, the homeowners are forbidden to use the airstrip without paying the railroad a fee for a license. PLF took over the case on appeal and filed briefs in the Ninth Circuit and orally argued. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Foss v. City of New Bedford, Massachusetts. Financially struggling senior citizen Deborah Foss used her life savings to buy a home. When she could not pay part of her 2016 tax debt, the city initiated a "tax taking," meaning the debt went on the books and began accruing 16% annual interest, subsequent tax bills, and administrative fees. The city sold its tax lien to a private investment company for $9,626-the amount Deborah owed the city. The company started the foreclosure process in court nine days later. The court foreclosed on the lien in September 2019, and handed absolute title and ownership of Deborah's home to the investor. The property's market value is $241,600, and Deborah owed only about $30,000, including fees, interest, and penalties. State law allows the company both to take her home and to keep the equity of $210,000. PLF sued on behalf of Deborah in state court. The city removed the case to federal court. The case subsequently settled. PLF did not seek or recover fees. Foster v. U.S. Department of Agriculture. Arlen and Cindy Foster are third-generation farmers in Miner County, South Dakota. They have a long history of responsible land conservation, including the tree line Arlen's father planted to prevent erosion. In the winter, deep snow drifts pile in the tree belt and come spring, the melting snow collects in a farm field. A federal agency ruled that the resulting mud puddle is a federally protected wetland, a determination that forces the Fosters to choose between farming their property and maintaining eligibility for federal benefits such as crop insurance. PLF represents the Fosters in federal court to challenge the Natural Resources Conservation Service's refusal to review whether one of the Fosters' farm fields contains a federally regulated wetland. The parties conducted discovery and filed cross-motions for summary judgment. The trial court ruled in favor of the government. PLF appealed to the Eighth Circuit, which affirmed. PLF plans to file a petition for writ of certiorari. Because this case is pending it is premature to seek fees. Friends of the Crazy Mountains v. Erickson. Activist groups sued the Forest Service and a private landowner in federal court, seeking to cancel a voluntary agreement to resolve conflict over public access to the Crazy Mountains across private property. The groups seek to compel the Forest Service to aggressively pursue claims of a possible easement across the landowners' property, even though the agency never formally established its existence. PLF represents private property owners M Hanging Lazy 3, LLC and Henry Guth, Inc. to defend private property rights by establishing that the process of formally establishing a public easement cannot be circumvented by suing an agency under the Administrative Procedures Act and that establishment of an easement by prescription is a taking requiring just compensation. The parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment and the court ruled in favor of the landowners' private property rights. The plaintiffs appealed and PLF defended the ruling in the Ninth Circuit. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Gearing v. City of Half Moon Bay. PLF represents Thomas and Daniel Gearing, father and son owners of six undeveloped parcels of land in Half Moon Bay, California. They want to build five single-family residences, two of which would provide housing for family members who otherwise cannot afford to live in California. The city rejected their plans to develop the property because that part of town lacks an overall land use plan. After the Gearings sued in federal court claiming that this rejection worked a regulatory taking, the city filed an eminent domain action in state court then successfully moved the federal court to abstain. PLF filed a petition for writ of certiorari advocating for full access to federal courts for takings claimants. The petition asks the Supreme Court to hold that federal courts must not abstain from deciding takings cases when federal courts are duty bound to adjudicate civil rights cases. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Hadian v. California Coastal Commission. San Luis Obispo County imposed a moratorium on new development in 2001, based on the limited supply of water available and desire to avoid overdraft conditions. However, some existing customers had already obtained water meters and could not be denied the right to develop. In 2007, these regulations were incorporated into the Local Coastal Program. PLF represents Al Hadian and Ralph Bookout in a state court lawsuit challenging the refusal to allow their development plans. Both men obtained water meters before 2001 and development permits from the County. The Coastal Commission then stepped in and denied the permits because it views any additional water use as a per se adverse impact. The Commission's rewriting of the county's program undermines the rule of law to deny individuals their property rights. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees.</ExplanationTxt>
      </SupplementalInformationDetail>
      <SupplementalInformationDetail>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Form 990, Part III, Line 4a</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>Hall v. Meisner. PLF represents several former Oakland County, Michigan, homeowners who lost their homes to tax foreclosure. Instead of selling the homes at auction, the City of Southfield took title to the properties by paying only the tax debt then gave the properties free of charge to a company that took large windfalls at the expense of the former owners. The company is controlled by key City officials. The owners sued to recover the equity in their homes but the trial court dismissed their claims. PLF took over the case and appealed to the Sixth Circuit, arguing that the City and related companies violated the former owners' constitutional rights and the doctrine of unjust enrichment when they took valuable homes that were worth more than the encumbering property tax debts. The Sixth Circuit agreed, holding that the city's retention of Hall's equity effected an unconstitutional taking, and remanding for just compensation. PLF opposed the county's petition for rehearing en banc, which was denied, and defeated the state Attorney General's motion to intervene. The appellate court awarded $505 in costs. The City petitioned the Supreme Court for a writ of certiorari on the takings issue, and PLF cross-petitioned on excessive fines. Both petitions were denied. The case is being litigated by private counsel on remand, but PLF retains an interest in future fees. HomeRoom, Inc. v. City of Shawnee, Kansas. PLF represents HomeRoom, Inc. (a property management company) and Val French in a federal lawsuit challenging Shawnee, Kansas's "co-living ban ordinance, which regulates the occupancy of homes on the basis of family relationships by prohibiting four or more unrelated persons from living together. When the ordinance was adopted, Val lived with her husband, their two adult sons, and the girlfriend of one of the sons. Fearing enforcement, the son and girlfriend moved out. Government exceeds its land-use authority when it regulates not only the use of land but the relationships among its users. Homeowners and individuals have a fundamental right to establish a household that meets their personal needs without undue government interference. The ordinance violates the due process and equal protections of the U.S. Constitution as well as state land use statutes. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Idaho Conservation League v. Poe. PLF represents Shannon Poe in the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals to challenge a district court decision that, in deferring to EPA regulations, held that Poe's suction dredge mining "added" pollutants to a "water of the United States and thus required a permit under section 402 of the Clean Water Act. Because suction dredge mining does not in fact add pollutants to regulated waters, it does not require a permit under section 402. At most, the discharge of "dredged or fill material" might have required a permit under section 404. PLF commenced briefing. Because this case is ongoing, it is premature to seek fees. Iten v. County of Los Angeles. Howard Iten is a retired auto mechanic who depends on rental income from a single commercial property in Lawndale, California. His current tenant is an auto repair franchisee who has refused to pay much of his rent during the COVID-19 pandemic, even though his business remained open the entire time. He owes Iten thousands of dollars in back rent but Iten cannot evict him under Los Angeles County's commercial eviction moratorium. The franchisee can avoid paying any current or back-rent until a full year after the moratorium expires and need never pay interest or fees. Iten must accept the franchisee's word that he is suffering a pandemic hardship. The moratorium undermines the lease contract without accomplishing anything to curb the emergency that supposedly justified its enactment. PLF represents Iten in a federal lawsuit to assert his rights under the federal Constitution's Contract Clause. The district court dismissed the complaint and PLF appealed to the Ninth Circuit. Because this case is ongoing, it is premature to seek fees. Johnson v. City of East Orange, New Jersey. In 2014, Lynette Johnson purchased commercial property in East Orange, N.J. to let two of her children run a business out of the location. She spent $55,000 to purchase the property and another $16,000 getting architectural plans and permits for renovations. Notices of her tax assessments and eventual tax lien and foreclosure were only ever sent to that property, and not to her nearby residential address in Newark where she has lived (and paid taxes) for nearly thirty years. By the time her tax lien was foreclosed in 2018, she owed a little under $20,000. The City sold the property to a private investor for $101k a few months later and kept all the proceeds. PLF represents Johnson in a state court lawsuit arguing that foreclosing and selling an entire property to satisfy a small tax debt, and retaining all proceeds, is a taking requiring just compensation. The parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment. Because this case is ongoing, it is premature to seek fees. Kagan v. County of Los Angeles. PLF represents Frank and Rachel Revere and David and Judith Kagan, who jointly own a duplex in Los Angeles. The Reveres reside in the downstairs unit and want their son and his family to move into the upstairs unit, which would require them to evict the existing tenant. They are thwarted by the county's rent stabilization ordinance that grants that tenant "protected" status and prohibits them from evicting him. After losing in the lower courts, PLF took over the case and filed a petition for writ of certiorari in the Supreme Court to ask whether a prohibition on evicting a tenant effects a physical taking of property by authorizing the tenant to continue possessing and occupying rental property at the expense of the owners' right to exclusively possess the property for their own family's use. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Knight v. Richardson Bay Regional Authority. Daniel Knight, a retired truck driver, owns and lives on a 35-foot sailboat on Richardson Bay, in Marin County, California. His boat is seaworthy and he sails regularly. A regional agency seeks to protect eelgrass on the floor of Richardson Bay by removing long-anchored boats from the water. It proposed to purchase Knight's boat only on the condition that he not become homeless in the county afterward. Unable to meet the condition because he lacks the financial means to purchase a home on land, Knight refused to sell. The Regional Authority then declared Knight's boat to be "marine debris and issued an order that it would seize the board within ten days. The order, issued without proper notice or a hearing, and without payment of just compensation, violates the unreasonable seizure, due process, and takings protections of the U.S. Constitution. PLF successfully obtained a preliminary injunction preventing the agency from seizing or destroying Knight's property. The case subsequently settled. PLF did not recover fees or costs. Lund v. United States. PLF represents Kristy Lund, as personal representative of the estate of John Lund, in a quiet title action against the federal government. The late John Lund brought a quiet title and takings case against the Bonneville Power Association, a federal power marketing agency in the Pacific Northwest. The district court dismissed the case, holding that the case was filed outside the applicable statute of limitations. PLF took over the case on appeal to argue that the Quiet Title Act's statute of limitations is not triggered by the recording of an easement, the federal government does not have an implicit access easement when the governing deed allows for an explicit easement on another portion of the property, and the Tucker Act's statute of limitations does not begin to run until after title has been quieted in the government's favor. Prevailing on these arguments will open the courthouse doors to more property owners. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Medeiros v. Virginia Dept. of Wildlife Resources. James Medeiros's property is posted with "No Trespassing" signs yet has been overrun frequently by hunting dogs and their owners. PLF represents James and other property owners with posted land to challenge the Commonwealth's so-called "right to retrieve" law, which allows sportsmen to enter private property any time of day, any time of year, to retrieve their hunting dogs, without needing to obtain the landowner's consent. PLF filed a state court lawsuit arguing that this law effects a per se physical taking in violation of the state and federal rights against uncompensated takings. The court granted the government's motion to dismiss and PLF appealed. Because this case is ongoing, it is premature to seek fees.</ExplanationTxt>
      </SupplementalInformationDetail>
      <SupplementalInformationDetail>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Form 990, Part III, Line 4a</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>Masucci v. Judy's Moody. Judy's Moody LLC is a holding company owned by Keith Dennis that holds title to his coastal home in Maine. For over 400 years, coastal property owners in Maine have held title to the intertidal zone (land between the mean high tide line and the low tide line). On April 21, 2021, activists unhappy with this settled law sued for a judicial declaration that all intertidal zones on Maine's coastline are public property. PLF represents Judy's Moody to argue that the right to control access to private property is an essential property right and that changing hundreds of years of settled private property rights raises serious Takings Clause concerns. The court ruled in favor of Judy's Moody that private property owners, not the state, own the intertidal zone, but allowed one part of the activists' lawsuit to continue. PLF filed a motion for reconsideration on that last issue. Litigation continues on the scope of the public easement and the parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment. Because this case is ongoing, it is premature to seek fees. Mendelson v. County of San Mateo, California. PLF represents Felix Mendelson in the Ninth Circuit, challenging the County's prohibition on development in designated sensitive habitat as a taking. Felix filed a coastal development permit to build a single family home on property that all parties know is a designated riparian corridor where all such construction is prohibited. Rather than condemning the land or denying Mendelson's permit so he could file an inverse condemnation claim, the government simply sat on the application and refused to issue a response. PLF will argue that local government cannot avoid rendering a final decision as a means to avoid liability for a taking. Appellate proceedings are stayed until July, 2023. Because the case is ongoing, it is premature to seek fees. New Mexico Cattle Growers Association v. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. In 2015, PLF submitted to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service a petition to delist the Southwestern willow flycatcher as an endangered species because a recent scientific study showed that the flycatcher should not be considered a separate subspecies. The Service denied the petition and refused to define the standards necessary for a population to qualify as a listable entity under the Endangered Species Act. This "we know when we see it" approach to taxonomy is arbitrary and capricious. PLF represents the New Mexico Cattle Growers Association, whose members are heavily burdened by critical habitat designations, and filed a complaint challenging the flycatcher listing in the district court for the District of Columbia. After a stay pending rulemaking was lifted, PLF filed a motion for summary judgment. Because this case is ongoing, it is premature to seek fees. Nieveen v. TAX 106. When Sandra Nieveen failed to pay property taxes on her $62,000 home, the county treasurer sold the tax certificate (a lien on the property) to a private firm, TAX 106, that paid approximately $3,500 in taxes on Nieveen's property. Three years later, TAX 106 notified Nieveen that she had three months to pay all accumulated taxes, interest, penalties, and costs, or she would lose her property. Nieveen did not pay. When Nieveen's right to redeem her property expired, the county treasurer issued the tax deed to the property to the private firm, granting it full title to the property. Nieveen lost everything. The Nebraska Supreme Court rejected Nieveen's statutory and constitutional claims, and PLF filed a petition for writ of certiorari on her behalf. The Court granted the petition, vacated the Nebraska Supreme Court decision, and remanded for reconsideration in light of PLF's victory in Tyler v. Hennepin County. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Pakdel v. City and County of San Francisco. A city ordinance requires anyone who converts a tenancy-in-common apartment interest into a condominium interest to give any existing non-owning tenant a right to a lifetime lease. On behalf of apartment owners Peyman Pakdel and Sima Chegini, PLF challenged the law as an unconstitutional taking and a violation of privacy interests protected by substantive due process and the Fourth Amendment. After winning a Supreme Court victory in 2021 on a procedural matter that allowed the Pakdels to proceed to the merits on their constitutional claims. On remand, PLF filed a first amended complaint, and defeated the city's motion to dismiss the unconstitutional conditions claim. Because litigation is ongoing, it is premature to seek additional fees. Pavlock v. Indiana. The Pavlock family has owned property along Indiana's Lake Michigan shoreline for generations. Last year, a ruling by the Indiana Supreme Court redefined state law to move lakefront owners' property lines from the water's edge or below to the lake's ordinary high-water mark, turning large swaths of private beach into public property without compensation. That judicial decision took their property even though the Pavlocks were not parties to the 2018 case. Courts, like the rest of the government, cannot take private property without paying for it. Representing the Pavlocks, PLF filed a federal lawsuit filed to restore beachfront property rights. The trial court granted the state's motion to dismiss and the appellate court issued an adverse decision. PLF filed a petition for writ of certiorari, which was denied. The case is closed. PLF did not seek or recover fees. Perez v. Wayne County, Michigan. In 2012, Erica Perez and her father bought a property containing a four-unit apartment home and a dilapidated single-family home in Detroit for $60,000. They spent three years fixing up the property for renters, with plans to move there themselves when her father retired. Though they paid property taxes each year, they unknowingly underpaid their 2014 taxes by $144. By 2017, Wayne County tacked on another $359 in interest, penalties and fees, foreclosed on their property, sold it for $108,000 and kept every cent. PLF filed a complaint filed in federal court challenging the tax surplus forfeiture law an unconstitutional under the Takings and Excessive Fines Clauses. After the Michigan Supreme Court's favorable decision in Rafaeli v. Oakland County, PLF moved for summary disposition. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Pietro Family Investments, LP v. California Coastal Commission. Chris Adamski, a Monterey County, California contractor, and his longtime mentor and friend Mike Pietro bought four properties in the county, planning to develop two houses to sell, and build one house for each of them. The California Coastal Commission (CCC) reversed the permits for three of the lots because Adamski and Pietro couldn't prove with 100% certainty that their land contains no archeological resources. The CCC effectively banned basements in the area and illegally expanded their oversight of local building regulations. Because the Commission has neither the jurisdiction nor the right to create arbitrary new land use laws through permitting, PLF represented Adamski and Pietro in a lawsuit against the commission in state court. The trial court denied the petition for writ of mandate, and PLF appealed on behalf of Pietro. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Preserve Responsible Shoreline Management v. City of Bainbridge Island, Washington. PLF took over representation of a coalition of Bainbridge Island homeowners to challenge the city's shoreline regulations as a violation of multiple statutory and constitutional provisions. After an adverse decision on procedural matters, PLF filed a petition for review in the Washington Supreme Court and a petition for writ of certiorari in the U.S. Supreme Court, both of which were denied. The case returned to the trial court for litigation on the merits. The trial court held in favor of the City and the appellate court affirmed. PLF filed a motion for reconsideration, which was denied. PLF filed a petition for review, which was denied. PLF will file a petition for writ of certiorari. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees.</ExplanationTxt>
      </SupplementalInformationDetail>
      <SupplementalInformationDetail>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Form 990, Part III, Line 4a</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>Rafaeli, LLC v. Oakland County, Michigan. After filing an amicus brief in the appellate court, PLF took over representation of Rafaeli, LLC, and Andre Ohanessian to ask the Michigan Supreme Court to review a lower court decision that permits counties to confiscate entire properties to satisfy tax debts without refunding any of the surplus proceeds of the sale to the former owner. This confiscation violates the federal and state constitutional provisions that prohibit the government from taking private property for public use without just compensation. The court unanimously ruled in favor of Rafaeli, eliminating the ability of the state to steal its citizens' home equity. The case proceeded as a class action in trial court, led by local counsel, then settled. PLF recovered $191,000 in fees from the settlement. Ralston v. County of San Mateo. Randy Ralston and Linda Mendiola own vacant property in a residentially-zoned area of San Mateo County. The county's Local Coastal Program flatly forbids any development on the property. Ralston sued in federal court alleging a taking without just compensation but the court dismissed it because he had not filed an application for a building permit and received a final decision whether it would allow the development (an inevitable refusal). PLF represented Ralston on appeal to the Ninth Circuit, filed briefs and orally argued. After an adverse decision, PLF filed a petition for rehearing en banc, which was denied. PLF filed a petition for writ of certiorari. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Ralston v. County of San Mateo. Randy Ralston and Linda Mendiola own vacant property in a residentially-zoned area of San Mateo County. The county's Local Coastal Program flatly forbids any development on the property. Ralston sued in federal court alleging a taking without just compensation but the court dismissed it because he had not filed an application for a building permit and received a final decision whether it would allow the development (an inevitable refusal). PLF represented Ralston on appeal to the Ninth Circuit, filed briefs and orally argued. After an adverse decision, PLF filed a petition for rehearing en banc, which was denied. PLF filed a petition for writ of certiorari. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Sabey v. Massachusetts Department of Children &amp; Families. When married couple Joshua Sabey and Sarah Perkins took their infant son to the hospital for a high fever, the staff x-rayed the infant to rule out pneumonia. Spotting a healed broken rib, the hospital detained Perkins and the baby for three days while they were questioned and ultimately released. At 1:00 a.m. the next night, the police arrived without a warrant, issuing threats, and demanding they turn over the children. After three months, the Sabeys were exonerated of all wrongdoing, the case against them permanently dismissed. PLF represents the family in federal district court in a lawsuit to challenge the agency's warrantless seizure of the children when there was no imminent risk of harm, in violation of the Fourth Amendment. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Sackett v. Environmental Protection Agency. After winning the right for the Sacketts to go to court to challenge the EPA's assertion of jurisdiction over alleged wetlands on their property in the U.S. Supreme Court (2012), PLF continued to represent the Sacketts on remand. PLF filed a motion for summary judgment seeking a ruling that the Sacketts' property does not contain wetlands subject to regulation under the Clean Water Act. The trial court issued an adverse decision and PLF appealed. The court issued an adverse opinion. PLF filed a petition for writ of certiorari, which was granted to determine the test for whether "navigable waters of the United States" exist on private property. Victory! The Supreme Court held that waters of the United States must be tied to commerce and that the Sacketts' land could not be waters of any kind. The Court awarded PLF $1,741.30 in costs. The case was remanded for further proceedings. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Seider v. City of Malibu, California. Dennis and Leah Seider were confronted by trespassers constantly traversing their beachfront property along the California coast and then refusing to leave because the land is not marked as private property. When the Seiders sought to put up a sign, the city said it was not permitted. Represented by PLF, they filed a federal lawsuit against the City of Malibu, challenging the restriction against signs to clearly mark where public access ends and private property begins at their beachfront home. Americans do not need government permission to mark the boundaries of their private property in order to enforce their fundamental right to exclude trespassers. Yet, Malibu's land use plan unconstitutionally demands that coastal property owners like the Seiders forfeit both their First Amendment and property rights. The court granted the city's motion to dismiss. PLF appealed and the Ninth Circuit affirmed, holding that the California Coastal Commission has "primary jurisdiction" over the Seider's proposed sign, and remanding. Litigation continues against the Coastal Commission. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Shands v. City of Marathon, Florida. The City of Marathon implemented a scheme to take the Shands family's property in the Florida Keys and avoid liability by promising credits towards a possible building permit elsewhere in Monroe County at an indeterminate future time, perhaps to be enjoyed by some third party. Representing the Shands family, PLF sued in state trial court challenging the city's total taking of the family's real property without the payment of just compensation. PLF seeks to establish that "transferable development rights" do not allow a government to avoid a finding of a taking and that "just compensation" equals financial compensation, not a chit to be traded for hard-to-define value. After a trial, the court issued an adverse decision. PLF appealed. Victory! The court held that the city unconstitutionally took the Shands' property without just compensation. The city petitioned for rehearing en banc that PLF opposed. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Sheffield v. Bush. Charles Sheffield is a long-time Texan and surfer who bought beachfront homes in Surfside Beach as a retirement investment. Merry Porter is a native Texan and resident of Surfside Beach who owns and uses a small beachfront home for rental income. In March 2021, without prior notice or compensation, the Texas General Land Office moved the public beach boundary at Surfside Beach to 200 feet inland of the low tide. This expansion of the beach converts Charles and Merry's residential properties into public property, taking away their privacy rights and ability to use and repair their properties. Government cannot turn private land into a public park without just compensation or due process, PLF represents Charles and Merry in a federal lawsuit challenging the Texas GLO order and moved for a preliminary injunction. PLF defeated the government's motion to dismiss and proceeded to the merits. After an adverse decision on a preliminary injunction, PLF appealed to the Fifth Circuit. The state then rescinded the order, but the court agreed with PLF that the case is not moot. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. State of California v. Bernhardt/Center for Biological Diversity v. Bernhardt/Animal Legal Defense Fund v. Bernhardt. In 2019, the Department of Interior changed the way that it applies the Endangered Species Act by rescinding an illegal rule. The changes offered additional protection for property owners and incentivized property owners to assist in the recovery of species by loosening restrictions on the ways that they can productively use their property. Seventeen states and environmental groups sued to overturn the changes. Representing rancher Ken Klemm, his company Beaver Creek Buffalo Co., and the Washington Cattlemen's Association, PLF successfully intervened in the lawsuits to maintain these protections for property owners. In the CBD and ADLF cases, the court granted the Defendants' motion to dismiss with leave to amend. In the State of California case, the court denied the Defendants' motion to dismiss. The cases were stayed while the agencies engaged in further rulemaking. PLF opposed further stays. The court agreed in a final decision, lifted the stays, and remanded to the agency for additional rulemaking. PLF appealed, then voluntarily dismissed the appeals when the district court reversed its own decision, with each party bearing its own costs and fees. This case is closed.</ExplanationTxt>
      </SupplementalInformationDetail>
      <SupplementalInformationDetail>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Form 990, Part III, Line 4a</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>State of Hawaii v. Williams. Don Williams is an elderly single father, raising a son, Sebastian. Despite his modest means, he purchased property in Maui in 1994 by his own resourcefulness and initiative and then rented it to the State. The income from the property was intended to provide for Sebastian's future, but the Hawaii's Harbors Division exercised its eminent domain power to take Williams' property, a parcel that the State was already leasing from Williams. The state improperly used the "undivided fee" rule when it appraised William's property at $2.67 million and excluded information about the property's income-generating potential. As the result of two trial court rulings, Williams may owe the state more than $1 million for the taking of his own property. PLF filed a notice of appearance to represent Don in the Hawaii Court of Appeals. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Stavrianoudakis v. California Department of Fish and Wildlife. PLF represents falconers and a falconry conservancy organization to challenge state and federal rules requiring warrantless inspection of their homes (a Fourth Amendment violation) and prohibiting photography or filming of falcons for commercial purposes (a First Amendment violation). The lawsuit also challenges the promulgation of these rules by a sub-level bureaucrat as a violation of the Constitution's Appointments Clause. PLF filed a complaint and a motion for preliminary injunction in federal district court. The state filed motions to dismiss. The court dismissed the Fourth Amendment claims but held that the First Amendment claims are likely to succeed and denied the motion to dismiss on that basis. The parties settled the First Amendment claims, including $178,000 in fees for PLF. PLF continues to litigate the Fourth Amendment claim on appeal to the Ninth Circuit. Tyler v. Hennepin County. Geraldine Tyler moved out of her Minneapolis condo in 2010, and rented an apartment in a safer area. While Geraldine and her family focused on her health and safety, she failed to pay property taxes on the condo and by 2015, her $2,300 tax debt (including costs and penalties) ballooned to $15,000. Hennepin County seized her condo and sold it the following year for $40,000. Even though Geraldine owed only $15,000, the county kept the surplus from the sale. PLF took over Geraldine's case in the Eighth Circuit to challenge government-sanctioned home equity theft, arguing that the county's refusal to refund the amount above and beyond what Geraldine owed was an unconstitutional taking or an excessive fine. After adverse rulings in the Eighth Circuit, PLF filed a petition for writ of certiorari, which was granted. Victory! The Supreme Court unanimously held that the County's retention of Tyler's equity beyond the amount of her debt was a taking without just compensation, in violation of the Fifth Amendment. The Court awarded PLF $1,391.20 in costs. The case was remanded for further proceedings. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Varela v. City of El Paso, Texas. After fire partially damaged Luis Varela's home, the city declared it a nuisance and ordered Varela to fix his home, warning it could be demolished if he did not. Varela immediately set out to make needed repairs, spending $30,000 for renovations, but while in the process, the city refused to grant him permits and eventually ordered demolition. When Varela sued, claiming demolition would be an unconstitutional taking of his property, Texas courts held his takings claim was barred because he did not judicially challenge the original nuisance determination. PLF petitioned the Texas Supreme Court for review and the Court ordered briefing on the merits. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Vondra v. City of Billings, Montana. A Billings ordinance requires all licensed massage therapy business owners, including home-practitioners, to agree to warrantless, unannounced searches and seizures as a condition of doing business. Refusal of even one such invasive search could result in fines, loss of license, or jail. Enforcement officers can open any containers or cupboards they please, including employee and client lockers, to look for evidence that anyone broke any law or regulation, civil or criminal. This includes client records, which often contain sensitive medical and insurance information that is normally protected under federal laws. PLF represents Theresa Vondra, a licensed massage therapist, in a federal lawsuit to ensure that governments cannot pursue social goals like fighting crime through warrantless fishing expeditions at the expense of livelihoods and property rights. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Wall v. Ainsworth. In 2018, the Wall family wanted to build a swimming pool next to their home on their property in Hollister Ranch, California. Like all landowners within the 14,500-acre, century-old working cattle ranch, the Walls needed a permit. Santa Barbara County approved the project; however, the California Coastal Commission denied the permit. The Commission said the construction would violate the Coastal Act's public access rules, even though the Walls' property is nearly a mile from the shoreline and no one has ever used their property to get to the coast. PLF filed a federal lawsuit challenging the Commission's arbitrary and unlawful permit denial. After defeating a motion to dismiss, the case is in the discovery phase. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Wayside Church v. County of Van Buren. In Michigan, when landowners fail to pay their property taxes, local governments take the property, sell it, and keep all the profits-no matter how small the debt or how valuable the property. As a result, local governments profit handsomely over the misfortune of their residents. For example, a few years ago, Wayside Church lost a piece of land worth a little over $200,000. Even after deducting outstanding tax debts, interest, penalties, and fees, Van Buren County made $189,250 in profit by foreclosing and auctioning the property. Having lost in the lower courts, PLF took over representation of Wayside Church and others who have lost their homes and equity to file a petition for writ of certiorari in the U.S. Supreme Court. The Court denied the petition. PLF successfully moved to reopen the case in the trial court and filed an amended class action complaint. After the Michigan Supreme Court's favorable decision in Raphaeli (see above), the case returned to the trial court, where it is litigated by local counsel as a class action. Because this case is pending, it would be premature to seek fees. Wilkins v. United States. PLF represents Montana residents Larry Wilkins and Jane Stanton, both of whom own property adjacent to the Bitterroot National Forest. The government invaded their property interests by advertising a public access road across their land, resulting in trespassing, illegal hunting, and other injuries. They sued in a quiet title action to determine the scope of an easement held by the United States over their private land. This is a significant issue for all private property owners whose property abuts federal land. Rejecting favorable findings and recommendations by a magistrate, the trial court ordered dismissal of the case on statute of limitations grounds. The court denied PLF's motion to alter or amend the judgment but also clarified its ruling for appeal. PLF appealed to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, filed briefs and conducted oral argument. The court issued an adverse decision. PLF filed a petition for rehearing, which was denied. PLF then filed a petition for writ of certiorari, which was granted. Victory! The Supreme Court ruled that Wilkins and Stanton may pursue their case against the federal government. Litigation continues in the district court. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Williams v. Alameda County. PLF represents John Williams and five other owners of residential rental properties in Oakland, California, as well as a housing provider trade association. The owners' respective tenants violated the terms of their leases in numerous respects, including the refusal to pay rent, the harassment of other tenants, and destruction and damage to the rental premises. The inability to evict these tenants due to a local eviction moratorium is a physical taking contrary to the Fifth Amendment and caused financial, physical, and emotional distress to the owners. PLF filed a lawsuit in federal court, followed by a motion for summary judgment. The district court rejected the facial claim and allowed the as-applied claim to move forward. PLF sought certification for immediate appeal to the Ninth Circuit, which was denied. Litigation continues in the trial court. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees.</ExplanationTxt>
      </SupplementalInformationDetail>
      <SupplementalInformationDetail>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Form 990, Part III, Line 4a</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>Yim v. City of Seattle. PLF represents owners of small rental properties to challenge the constitutionality of Seattle's "Fair Chance Housing Ordinance," which restricts a residential landlord from considering a tenant applicant's criminal history. PLF filed the complaint in Washington state court and Seattle removed it to federal court. The parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment. While these were pending, Seattle successfully moved to certify the question of what standard of review is appropriate to the Washington Supreme Court and the federal litigation was subsequently stayed. After the Washington Supreme Court ruled that the state due process clause is equivalent to its federal counterpart, litigation continued on the owners' due process and First Amendment claims. The federal district court granted the city's motion for summary judgment and PLF appealed to the Ninth Circuit. The Ninth Circuit struck down one aspect of the law as violating the First Amendment and upheld another aspect against the due process challenge. The Court ordered each side to bear its own costs. The city petitioned for rehearing en banc, and PLF filed a conditional cross-petition. Both petitions were denied. PLF plans to file a cert petition on the due process issue. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees.</ExplanationTxt>
      </SupplementalInformationDetail>
      <SupplementalInformationDetail>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Form 990, Part III, Line 4a</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>Separation of Powers: The Constitution's structure was designed to protect liberty. It is a charter of enumerated powers, limiting the scope of federal authority and establishing a separation of legislative, executive, and judicial powers. PLF fights to end the modern administrative state, including limiting judicial deference to legislative and administrative judgments; restore separation of powers against improper delegation of authority to bureaucrats and accountability when those bureaucrats exceed their authority; defining the limited scope of federal power under the Commerce Clause; reviving the doctrine of enumerated powers; and ensuring due process of law. Bell v. Raimundo. PLF represents Karen Bell and Steven Rash in a federal lawsuit challenging an amendment to the Gulf of Mexico Fishery Management plan on the grounds that Gulf of Mexico Fishery Management Council controlling the issuance of the plan is unconstitutionally structured with members appointed in violation of the Appointments Clause. Bell is a fish-seller and Rash a fisherman. The challenged plan amendment significantly reduces the commercial Greater Amberjack fishing quota, harming Bell's and Rash's businesses. Because this case is pending, it is premature to see fees. Bikeyah v. Biden. Representing landowners, hunters, outdoor sportsmen, and ranchers, PLF attorneys successfully moved to intervene in this case brought by environmentalists to challenge the President's authority to rescind or reduce previously designated national monuments and filed briefs in the case. Litigation is ongoing. Because this case is pending, it would be premature to seek fees. Bradford v. Walsh. Duke Bradford owns and operates opened Arkansas Valley Adventures (AVA), a Colorado company employing 250 people who provide a full slate of outdoor experiences, including guided, multi-day river rafting wilderness trips. Because Colorado's rivers flow through federal land, rafting businesses must obtain special use permits permitted by federal law, for which they pay a fixed percentage of service fees. The U.S. Department of Labor has ordered all federal contractors to pay a $15-per-hour minimum wage, plus overtime, starting January 30, 2022. The rule's absurdly broad definition of "contractors" includes 45,000 private firms that provide concessions or recreational services-like rafting outfitters-whose only ties to the federal government are special land use permits or licenses. Representing Duke, and the nonprofit Colorado River Outfitters Association, PLF filed a federal lawsuit challenging the executive order mandating workers' pay structure and sought a preliminary injunction. The court denied the preliminary injunction and PLF appealed. Meanwhile, PLF filed a motion for summary judgment in trial court. The Tenth Circuit stayed the order and the trial court proceedings pending resolution of the interlocutory appeal. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Clementine Co. v. Adams/Clementine Co. v. De Blasio. PLF represents small venue theatres and comedy clubs in Manhattan that seat fewer than 200 customers. They are challenging a law that forbids these venues from admitting customers without requiring proof of COVID-19 vaccination. However, if the venues were to host a church service, the city requires no proof of vaccination. This differential and restrictive treatment violates the First and Fourteenth Amendments. The unequal mandate burdens and stigmatizes businesses that already are struggling to rebound from the city's lockdown policies. PLF filed a complaint in federal district court and sought a preliminary injunction to vindicate the venues' constitutional rights. The preliminary injunction was denied and PLF appealed to the Second Circuit, which dismissed the appeal as moot and vacated the lower court decision. Litigation continued in the trial court and the district court ruled against Clementine on standing and mootness grounds. The case is closed. PLF did not seek or recover fees. In a similar challenge, Clementine v. De Blasio, the case settled with Clementine receiving nominal judgment of $1.00. Both sides bore their own fees and costs. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau v. Townstone Financial, Inc. PLF represents Townstone Financial, Inc. and its CEO and principal shareholder, Barry Sturner, to defend against a civil action brought by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) in federal district court. CFPB alleges that discussions on a Townstone-sponsored radio show and podcast concerning crime, policing, and real estate in economically depressed neighborhoods in Chicago had the effect of discouraging loan applicants based on race. The case includes statutory and First Amendment claims. Victory! The Court dismissed CFPB's complaint with prejudice on the grounds that the challenged regulation is not authorized by law and that the agency's decision to the contrary is entitled to no deference. The agency appealed. As litigation is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Death of the Fox Brewing Co. v. N.J. Division of Alcoholic Bev. Control (ABC). PLF represents Chuck Garrity, a longtime home brew hobbyist who opened Death of the Fox Brewing Company, a combination microbrewery and coffee shop. The ABC agency promulgated a "special ruling" creating strict new rules for craft breweries. But the rules were implemented without the required notice-and-comment procedures, running afoul of the N.J. Administrative Procedures Act. Moreover, because it outlaws advertising of "on-premises special events," the rules violate the First Amendment. PLF appealed the agency action in state court. Because litigation is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Doe v. U.S. Dept. of Justice. PLF represents John Doe and the Alliance for Constitutional Sex Offense Laws in a federal lawsuit to challenge a final rule issued by the U.S. Department of Justice imposing registration requirements under the Sex Offense Registration and Notification Act on those previously convicted of certain offenses. Doe's prior misdemeanor offense has been expunged under California law, and he has no obligation to register as a sex offender under state law. In fact, it is impossible for him to do so. Nevertheless, the U.S. Attorney General asserted the authority and unlimited discretion to require Doe to register and presume his guilt for a federal crime if he fails to do so. PLF filed a complaint and moved for an injunction. Victory! The court granted the injunction and declared the registration requirement unconstitutional. The case continues on the merits in district court. Because litigation is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) v. Credit Bureau Center, LLC/FTC v. Consumer Defense, LLC/FTC v. Elite IT Partners. After the Supreme Court ruled that the FTC cannot obtain disgorgement as a remedy under one provision of its authorizing statute, the Commission moved to achieve the same remedy under a different provision (Section 19). Because Section 19 plainly does not permit such a remedy, PLF took over representation of Credit Bureau Center in the Seventh Circuit, which was briefed, and Consumer Defense in district court, solely to challenge the FTC's authority to impose disgorgement as a remedy for regulatory violations. Litigation is ongoing. The court ruled against Elite IT Partners and PLF appealed to the Tenth Circuit. PLF is not eligible to receive fees in these cases. Fehily v. Biden. Commercial fishermen are regulated by the Endangered Species Act to protect marine life, the Magnuson Stevens Fisheries Act to safeguard against overfishing, and the Marine Sanctuaries Act, which allows multiple uses-including fishing-while comprehensively managing conservation of resources. In October 2021, President Biden invoked the Antiquities Act to proclaim 5,000 square miles (3.2 million acres) of ocean as the Northeast Canyons and Seamounts Marine National Monument. The proclamation ignores limitations in the Act. The submerged land is not on federal lands. "Ecosystems and "biodiversity" are not protected objects under the Act. And the proclamation bans commercial fishing within those waters, a legislative power never delegated by Congress to the president. PLF represents Pat Fehily and Tim Malley, a 50-year fishing veteran and vessel owner in a federal lawsuit challenging this violation of the Constitution's separation of powers and threat to the right of commercial fishermen to earn an honest living. At the clients' request, the case was voluntarily dismissed. PLF did not seek or recover fees.</ExplanationTxt>
      </SupplementalInformationDetail>
      <SupplementalInformationDetail>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Form 990, Part III, Line 4a</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>Garrison v. U.S. Dept. of Education. PLF represents Frank Garrison in a putative class action in federal court to challenge student loan cancelation implemented by the U.S. Department of Education. As directed by President Biden, the Department intends to cancel federal student loan debt on or about October 1, 2022. However, the putative statutory basis for this action, the Higher Education Relief Opportunities for Students Act (HEROES Act), 20 U.S.C. 1098aa et seq., does not allow this unilateral action. This case seeks to enforce basic limits on the Executive Branch's ability to use an inapplicable statute as a pretext for a transformational, massive, and highly political economic action. The district court dismissed the case on standing grounds. PLF submitted an amended complaint and request for preliminary injunction. The complaint was dismissed and injunction denied. The Seventh Circuit refused to enjoin the cancelation and PLF applied to the Supreme Court for an injunction, which was denied. The case remains at the Seventh Circuit in abeyance pending the Supreme Court's decision in Biden v. Nebraska. The Supreme Court agreed with PLF that the HEROES Act did not authorize the loan cancellation. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Ghost Golf v. Newsom. At Ghost Golf in Fresno, California, the weeks leading up to Halloween mark the peak season for the haunted house-themed miniature golf center, earning enough money for owner Daryn Coleman and his family to weather the springtime slowdown. However, Ghost Golf was by Governor Gavin Newsom's COVID-related business shutdown orders, leaving the owners with no income while still facing rental obligations and other business expenses. Worse, Newsom implemented his complex, arbitrary scheme with neither legislative authority nor an expiration date. With their livelihoods-and life savings-on the line, PLF represents Ghost Golf and another California small business owner in a lawsuit filed in California state court. The court denied a motion for preliminary injunction and PLF appealed. The appellate court affirmed. Proceedings on the merits continue in the trial court, where PLF defeated a motion to dismiss and filed a motion for summary judgment. The court ruled for the government and PLF appealed. As litigation is ongoing, it is premature to seek fees. Goodwood Brewing Company, LLC v. Beshear. Since the pandemic began, Kentucky Governor Andy Beshear used his emergency powers to unilaterally enact COVID-19-related policies. In February 2021, the legislature passed three bills to limit the governor's use of pandemic-related emergency orders. Gov. Beshear immediately sued, claiming these new laws unconstitutionally interfere with his broad emergency authority. Representing Goodwood Brewing Company and other breweries and restaurants, PLF filed a lawsuit in state court challenging the governor's enforcement of COVID-related orders which expired under the new legislation. Even during a pandemic, each branch of government must adhere to the constitutional provision of separation of powers, which are the main protection of individual liberty. PLF prevailed and obtained a temporary injunction and the governor appealed. The appellate court transferred the case to the Kentucky Supreme Court, where PLF presented oral argument. The decision (along with a consolidated case) was largely favorable and the court remanded for further proceedings. PLF filed a petition for rehearing in the Kentucky Supreme Court, which was denied. In the trial court, a joint dismissal is pending. PLF will not seek or recover fees. Humbyrd v. Raimondo. Wes Humbyrd has been a part of Alaska's commercial Goodwood Brewing Company, LLC v. Beshear. Since the pandemic began, Kentucky Governor Andy Beshear used his emergency powers to unilaterally enact COVID-19-related policies. In February 2021, the legislature passed three bills to limit the governor's use of pandemic-related emergency orders. Gov. Beshear immediately sued, claiming these new laws unconstitutionally interfere with his broad emergency authority. Representing Goodwood Brewing Company and other breweries and restaurants, PLF filed a lawsuit in state court challenging the governor's enforcement of COVID-related orders which expired under the new legislation. Even during a pandemic, each branch of government must adhere to the constitutional provision of separation of powers, which are the main protection of individual liberty. PLF prevailed and obtained a temporary injunction and the governor appealed. The appellate court transferred the case to the Kentucky Supreme Court, where PLF presented oral argument. The decision (along with a consolidated case) was largely favorable and the court remanded for further proceedings. PLF filed a petition for rehearing in the Kentucky Supreme Court, which was denied. In the trial court, a joint dismissal is pending. PLF will not seek or recover fees. salmon industry for 53 years. He draws his catch-and his livelihood-from Cook Inlet. A regulation proposed by the North Pacific Fishery Management Council, however, will permanently close the inlet's federal waters to commercial salmon fishing, not because of overfishing but because the council deemed it too hard to coordinate management duties with the state. The council's members wield enormous federal authority yet are neither appointed as officers of the United States nor subject to appropriate oversight by the president or his officers. The Constitution forbids bureaucrats from exercising significant federal policymaking powers unless they are under the control of the president. On behalf of Wes and two other fishermen, PLF filed a complaint in federal court to restore their right to earn an honest living without interference by an illegally formed agency and its unlawful regulation. The case was consolidated with another, related case, and PLF filed a motion for summary judgment, which was denied. The clients opted not to appeal. This case is closed. PLF did not seek or recover fees. Leachco, Inc. v. Consumer Products Safety Comm'n. PLF represents Leachco, Inc., a family-owned manufacturer based in Oklahoma. The Commission filed an in-house administrative action against Leachco alleging that its infant-lounging pillow (the "Podster") contains defects creating a substantial risk of injury. The allegation is specious. Leachco has sold 180,000 Podsters with explicit instructions and warnings that the Podster should be used only for awake and supervised infants. Unfortunately, two babies died when parents disregarded instructions and warnings and placed them in danger. Leachco has vigorously defended itself. PLF filed a federal lawsuit in Oklahoma seeking a stay of the administrative proceedings and challenging the proceedings on constitutional grounds as well as defending Leachco against the substantive "defect" allegations. The court denied the request for preliminary injunction. PLF appealed to the Tenth Circuit, which declined to enjoin and PLF filed an emergency application to the Supreme Court, which denied it. Litigation continues in the trial court. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Lofstad v. Raimondo. PLF represents Raymond Lofstad and Gus Lovgren, commercial fishermen who operate in federal waters in the Atlantic Ocean. These waters are managed by the Mid-Atlantic Fisheries Council, which issued new regulations significantly restricting the fishing of flounder, scup, and Black Sea bass. With their livelihoods imperiled, Lofstad and Lovgren filed a federal lawsuit against the Secretary of Commerce and an agency within the department, the National Marine Fisheries Service, on the grounds that the Council is structured in violation of the Constitution's Appointments Clause and, therefore, its regulations are void. Proper appointments are important to ensure accountability. PLF filed a motion for summary judgment. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Mayfield v. U.S. Dept. of Labor. PLF represents Robert Mayfield, who owns more than a dozen restaurants in and around Austin, Texas, in a federal lawsuit against the Department of Labor (DOL) to stop a rule that limits his ability to offer his managers the kinds of compensation packages he thinks best. The DOL's regulations are less about correctly interpreting the original statute, and more about shoving workers into the hourly box. Workers and employers would be better served by choosing the terms of their employment for themselves. PLF argues that the DOL has no authority to dictate salary level and overtime requirements for management-level employees that Congress exempted from hourly pay requirements. Both parties filed motions for summary judgment. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees.</ExplanationTxt>
      </SupplementalInformationDetail>
      <SupplementalInformationDetail>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Form 990, Part III, Line 4a</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>Michigan Association of Public Schools Academies, et al. v. U.S. Dept. of Education. PLF represents a coalition of charter schools in Michigan and Ohio in a federal lawsuit challenging the Department of Education's illegal rule that punishes successful charter schools nationwide. The federal Charter Schools Program makes grants of hundreds of millions of dollars to increase the number of high-quality charter schools. Congress gave clear instructions and criteria for distributing these funds; however, the DOE issued a new rule requiring applicants (1) to prove that traditional public schools are over-enrolled, not just failing to serve the needs of their students; (2) to seek approval from existing public schools; and (3) to show that they are not serving too many students who are racial minorities. The DOE has no authority to issue these new rules, and cannot advance a policy agenda contrary to Congress' clear instructions. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Murphy v. Raimondo. PLF represents Maureen Murphy and John Huddleston in a federal lawsuit challenging the Census Bureau's authority to compel individuals under threat of criminal prosecution to provide private information through two sampling surveys. PLF argues that the open-ended statutes authorizing the Census Bureau to collect information through the American Community Survey and American Housing Survey violate the nondelegation doctrine, invade the right to privacy, and compel speech in violation of the First Amendment. PLF also argues that the Bureau's interpretations of the statutes and regulations should receive to deference from the court. PLF sought to certify a class action. The trial court ruled in favor of the government on grounds of ripeness. PLF appealed to the Ninth Circuit. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Peters Brothers, Inc. v. Pennsylvania Dept. of Environmental Protection. PLF represents Peters Brothers and other small trucking companies and trade associations in a state court lawsuit challenging a Pennsylvania regulation that automatically incorporates any changes to California's regulations governing heavy diesel vehicles. The incorporation of California's regulations makes it more costly for trucking and busing companies to update their fleets, causing customers to respond by buying and registering trucks in other states. Only Pennsylvania's elected representatives can make laws for Pennsylvania residents; a state that outsources its lawmaking authority to another state violates both statutory law and the nondelegation doctrine. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Phillip B. v. Mike Faust, and Arizona Department of Child Safety. A troubled teen housed at a group home accused Mr. B of abusing another teen because Mr. B. placed his hand on the teen's shoulder to calm him down. An administrative law judge, after trial, exonerated Mr. B., a group home manager for troubled teens, of the child-abuse charge after DCS failed to prove the elements of the charge. DCS, a single-director agency, appealed the judge's decision to its director. The director deleted the judge's factual and credibility findings, and rejected the judge's conclusions of law. As a result, Mr. B.'s name was placed on the child-abuse registry for 25 years. The state trial court deferred to the director's (as opposed to the judge's) findings of fact. PLF represents Mr. B. to challenge the administrative adjudication scheme under the Due Process Clauses of the state and federal constitutions, and the Separation-of-Powers Clause of the Arizona Constitution. Victory! The court issued a favorable decision and DCS appealed, then withdrew its appeal. The case is closed. PLF did not seek or recover fees. Sarra L. v. Faust. PLF represents Sarra L. in Arizona state court to reverse the Department of Child Safety's decision that (1) labeled her a neglectful parent for buying groceries while her seven-year-old son played at a nearby safe, public park, and (2) added her name to the list (called the Central Registry) of child abusers where it will stay for 25 years. This case is a companion to the Phillip B. v. Faust case noted above and similarly seeks to end judicial deference to regulators, revive due process protections in administrative hearings, and hold agencies and bureaucrats accountable for the mistreatment of citizens. PLF filed a lawsuit and successfully sought a stay of the agency decision, removing Sarra's name from the registry while the case proceeds. Victory! The state confessed error and Sarra's name was removed from the registry permanently. PLF moved for $96,541.90 in attorneys' fees and $4,235.91 in costs; the motion is pending. Skipper, et al. v. U.S. Fish &amp; Wildlife Service, et al. The Skipper family has owned forestland in Clarke County, Alabama, since 1902, which it manages for timber production and conservation. In 1956 they established the Scotch Wildlife Management Area to voluntarily open their land for the state's wildlife conservation efforts and outdoor recreation. In February 2020, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service designated the Skipper family's land as critical habitat for the black pinesnake, thus reducing the land's value, triggering burdensome regulatory requirements, and penalizing them for their past conservation activities. The agency imposed these burdens based on a single sighting of a single snake over a 25-year period. It also sidestepped cost-benefit requirements that Congress imposed to avoid irrational regulations like this. On behalf of the Skipper family, Forest Landowners Association, and Goodloe family, PLF sued the Service in the Southern District of Alabama. The parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment; PLF briefed and argued the case. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Tibbitts v. California Coastal Commission. David Tibbitts and his wife live in a small, 1932 home near the ocean. After David became wheelchair-bound, his family wanted to raze the house and build a new, accessible dwelling. The CCC prevented the demolition unless the Tibbitts tore down a protective seawall. Both the seawall and the existing home are legal as is, as they predate the California Coastal Act. The CCC refused to schedule a hearing on the matter for over two years. On the Tibbitts' behalf, PLF filed a petition to compel the Commission to hold a hearing, and to revive due process protections in administrative hearings. The petition was denied and PLF filed a new complaint alleging due process violations. This prompted action from the Commission, which finally approved the permit. Subsequently, PLF dismissed the complaint. The case is closed. PLF did not seek or recover fees. Twism Enterprises, LLC v. State Board of Registration for Professional Engineers and Surveyors. PLF represents Twism Enterprises, LLC in the Supreme Court of Ohio to challenge judicial deference to agency determinations. Twism Enterprises applied to the State Board of Registration for Professional Engineers for a certificate to provide engineering services. A statute requires Twism to designate one or more "full-time partners, managers, members, officers, or directors" to be responsible for its professional-engineering services. Twism used an independent contractor as its engineering manager and the Board denied Twism's application on that basis. The Court of Appeals held that it was required to defer to the Board's interpretation. Such deference violates the separation of powers, which authorizes only the judiciary to say what the law is. PLF successfully petitioned the Ohio Supreme Court to review the case and filed briefs on the merits. Victory! The Court refused to defer to the agency and ruled in favor of Twism. The case is closed. PLF did not seek or recover fees. United States v. Rare Breed Triggers, LLC. PLF represents Rare Breed Triggers, LLC, Rare Breed Firearms, LLC, Lawrence DeMonico, and Kevin Maxwell in federal district court. This case concerns the U.S. Department of Justice's ability to rewrite the federal criminal law through a regulation, and then enforce it, despite the regulation having been struck down by a federal court. The DOJ issued a regulation that bans "bump stocks"- devices that allow semiautomatic rifles to be fired rapidly, simulating the action of a machine gun. The bump-stock ban was a blatantly political effort by the Trump Administration to outlaw a device that Congress did not ban and the Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms Division viewed, until 2018, as entirely legal under applicable statutes. PLF opposes this executive branch power grab and filed a motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction. Due to a conflict that arose after filing, PLF withdrew from the case and did not seek or recover fees.</ExplanationTxt>
      </SupplementalInformationDetail>
      <SupplementalInformationDetail>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Form 990, Part III, Line 4a</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>Villegas v. Environmental Protection Agency. PLF represents Thomas and Amy Villegas, who own undeveloped property in Nebraska that they intend to use for hunting and other recreational activities. They cleared the land of dead trees and invasive vegetation and created an access road. A neighbor reported their activity to the EPA, which is prosecuting them for violating the Clean Water Act and seeking $300,000 in penalties in an agency procedure run under its own rules, and using its own employees as judges. The Constitution guarantees basic principles of fairness, including the right to a fair trial before an impartial judge and jury. This means a real court of law, not court-like procedures set by executive agencies. PLF filed a complaint in federal district court and moved for a preliminary injunction. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Walmsley v. Federal Trade Commission. PLF represents Bill Walmsley, John Moss, and the Iowa Horsemen's Benevolent and Protective Association, who are subject to the federal Horse Integrity and Safety Act of 2020, which created the Horseracing Integrity and Safety Authority to regulate racetrack safety and horse doping nationwide. The Authority requires anyone in the horse industry to register and pay yearly fees. The burdensome rules and regulations from the Horse Act and the accompanying regulations make it difficult for independent horse owners like Walmsley to continue in the horse business. The Authority suffers from multiple constitutional violations because it is a private nonprofit corporation making nationwide rules with no accountability to Congress or the people. The President cannot appoint or remove Authority members. And the Authority adjudicates all disputes. PLF filed a lawsuit challenging the Act and the Authority in federal court, and sought a preliminary injunction. Because the case is ongoing, it is premature to seek fees. Washington Cattlemen's Ass'n v. Environmental Protection Agency/Oregon Cattlemen's Ass'n v. Environmental Protection Agency/North Dakota v. Environmental Protection Agency/ New Mexico Cattle Growers' Association v. EPA/Pasqua Yaqui Tribe v. EPA. The EPA issued an "internal guidance" document redefining jurisdictional waters under the Clean Water Act in violation of Administrative Procedure Act rule-making procedures and the U.S. Constitution. Representing cattlemen's associations whose members are adversely affected by the overly-expansive reach of the EPA's "Navigable Waters Rule," PLF filed complaints in multiple states to overturn it. Pasqua Yaqui was voluntarily dismissed and is closed. All other cases were stayed pending resolution of Sackett v. EPA by the Supreme Court. Because litigation is ongoing in all these cases, it is premature to seek fees. Williams v. California Department of Fish &amp; Wildlife. Chris Williams wants to obtain a gill and trammel net permit from an existing permit holder. The Department says that he is not qualified because he does not have any experience using gill or trammel nets. Yet such experience is only legal if one has a permit. PLF filed a federal lawsuit because the agency no longer issues gillnet permits, so a transfer application is the only way to legally fish. The law allows permits to transfer to qualified fishermen, but the agency's reinterpretation requires applicants to demonstrate skills that only permit holders can legally perform. The agency's refusal to carry out its nondiscretionary duty to transfer his permit violated the state fish and game code. PLF filed a petition for writ of mandate in Ventura County Superior Court. Victory! The court ordered the agency to transfer the permit. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Wille v. Raimondo. PLF represents Hawaii residents involved in the local swim-with-dolphins industry as boat captains, dolphin guides, or therapists to challenge a rule issued by the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) that prohibits swimming with or approaching spinner dolphins. This regulation will destroy an entire industry without regard for the value individuals receive from interacting with the playful animals. It even forces people who are approached by dolphins to swim away and ignore the animals' natural curiosity. PLF filed a lawsuit in federal district court in Maryland arguing that the rule violates the Appointments Clause because it was issued by a NMFS career civil servant who was neither nominated by the President and confirmed by the Senate, nor appointed by a head of department or other entity competent to appoint "inferior" officers. PLF defeated the government's motion to dismiss and litigation continues on a motion for summary judgment. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Equality and Opportunity: PLF is pursuing a multi-front campaign to halt the reemergence of governmental discrimination based on race, sex, or group entitlement and to advance a positive vision of civil rights with individual liberty at its core, centered on a demand to remove legal barriers that separate people from opportunity. PLF's goal is to free individuals to rise based on their choices, character, and ability. We therefore demand removal of state-imposed barriers to opportunity, leading from the principles of equal protection and due process that guided the architects of the Fourteenth Amendment. While overt racial barriers have largely been removed from our society, economic regulations continue to pervasively impede the pursuit of one's livelihood. This is especially true for those of lesser means. Economic liberty has been the most neglected basic civil right and PLF therefore finds it especially worthy of attention. Abad v. Bonham/Burke v. Bonham. Several state and federal laws and regulations protect endangered species affected by commercial swordfish fishing. The government issued new rules, however, that threaten to destroy the freedom of responsible fisherman to earn a living. PLF represents commercial fishermen in two federal lawsuits challenging California's ban on the catch of swordfish by drift gill nets in federal waters pursuant to a federal permit, and the ban on landing and sale of such swordfish in the state as preempted by federal law under the U.S. Constitution's Supremacy Clause. In Abad v. Bonham, the court denied the state defendants' motion to dismiss and PLF's motion for preliminary injunction. Rather than proceed to a ruling on the merits, the state reinterpreted the rules to permit Abad and Burke to use the gill nets. Consequently, the parties settled and dismissed the case. PLF did not seek or recover fees. Association For Education Fairness v. Montgomery County Public Schools. PLF represents Association for Education Fairness, a group of mostly Asian-American parents whose children are shut out of the Montgomery County (Maryland) magnet school program because of changing criteria designed to make the magnet schools reflect the County's racial demographics. PLF's federal lawsuit challenges the county's admissions policy as unconstitutional racial discrimination. Racial balancing is unconstitutional whether done through overt or covert means. PLF defeated the school board's motion to dismiss and filed an amended complaint. The school board again moved to dismiss and the court granted the motion. PLF sought relief from judgment based on new information. When that was denied, PLF appealed to the Fourth Circuit, and briefed the case. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Art and Antique Dealers v. Seggos. The federal Endangered Species Act allows for the sale of certain antiques containing ivory, as well as non-antiques containing a de minimis amount of ivory, in interstate and international commerce. New York State limits intrastate sales of items containing ivory to only antiques containing no more than 20% ivory. Although it cannot ban items authorized by federal law, New York has burdened the sale of ivory antiques by prohibiting their display in New York antique dealers' stores. Dealers may show photographs of the antiques to prospective interstate buyers who visit their stores, so long as they include a disclaimer that the item not for sale in New York." The dealers alleged a First Amendment right to display the actual items with that same disclaimer, but were rejected by a federal trial court. PLF represents two antique dealer trade associations on appeal to the Second Circuit. PLF filed briefs and conducted oral argument. Because this case is pending it is premature to seek fees.</ExplanationTxt>
      </SupplementalInformationDetail>
      <SupplementalInformationDetail>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Form 990, Part III, Line 4a</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>Barilla v. City of Houston. Tony Barilla is an accomplished accordionist who wishes to busk-that is, play in public for tips-in the streets of Houston. But Houston bans busking in most places and where it is allowed, performers must obtain a permit and permission from abutting property owners of the performance site, establishing a "heckler's veto" over the busker's speech. The First Amendment protects Tony's right to earn extra money while engaging in free expression. Representing Barilla, PLF sued in federal district court to vindicate his First Amendment rights and establish the principle that speech that is motivated by money is just as protected by the Constitution as any other kind of speech. The court granted the city's motion to dismiss. PLF appealed to the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, which agreed with PLF, reversed the district court and remanded for proceedings on the merits. PLF was awarded $561 in court costs for the appeal. Back in the trial court, both parties moved for summary judgment. Victory! The district court ruled that the city had no evidence whatsoever to justify the busking ordinance and it therefore violated the First Amendment. PLF seeks $208,821.50 in fees and awaits the court's order. Boston Parent Coalition for Academic Excellence v. School Committee of Boston. PLF represents a group of students, parents, alumni, and future applicants to Boston's Exam Schools. The group's mission is to promote excellent and merit-based admissions while supporting diversity by improving the K-6 pipeline in Boston public schools. They sued in federal court to challenge Boston's decision to overhaul admissions to pursue racial balance by imposing quotas based on applicants' postal zip codes. The parent coalition lost in district court and PLF took over representation on appeal to the First Circuit and filed briefs to argue that it violates the constitution to manipulate admissions processes to obtain desired racial outcomes. PLF orally argued. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Californians for Equal Rights Foundation v. County of Alameda, California. Alameda County requires prime contractors to subcontract 15% of applicable government construction contracts to minority-owned businesses or show "good faith efforts" that they attempted to do so. The set-asides force general contractors to discriminate against subcontractors, and in many cases, they work to exclude subcontractors in certain fields from obtaining jobs just because they are not minority-owned. PLF represents the Californians for Equal Rights Foundations and several individuals, including a longtime California contractor, to challenge these set-asides in federal court as violating the federal and state constitutional guarantees of equal protection under the law. The county moved for judgment on the pleadings, which was granted, on the grounds that the lawsuit was barred by the statute of limitations. PLF appealed to the Ninth Circuit. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Chinese American Citizens Alliance of Greater New York v. Adams. New York City operates eight specialized high schools that are among the best in the city, public or private. State law offers a path to admission for low-income students who score below the Admissions Test cutoff, up to 5% of the available ninth-grade seats. The City of New York changed the admissions criteria to reserve 20% of the ninth-grade seats for low-income students, explicitly for the purpose of increasing the percentage of black and Hispanic students while decreasing the percentage of Asian-American students. PLF represents parents of Asian-American students in a federal lawsuit challenging this change as violating the Equal Protection Clause. The district court granted the City's motion for summary judgment and PLF appealed to the Second Circuit, filed briefs, and argued. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Chubb v. Boyd. PLF represents Katie Chubb and Augusta Birth Center in a federal lawsuit to challenge the Georgia's Certificate of Need (CON) regulations for freestanding birth centers. These regulations require any new childbirth services to seek the cooperation of their direct competitors in order to secure a license to operate. The regulations are an unconstitutional restriction on both Ms. Chubb's right to provide critical childbirth care and the right of Georgia mothers to access those services. Mothers, not the state, should be able to choose the safe and comfortable circumstances under which they give birth. The district court granted the government's motion to dismiss on standing grounds. PLF filed a motion for reconsideration or leave to amend the complaint. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Coalition for TJ v. Fairfax County School Board. Virginia's Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology, or TJ, is the nation's top-ranked public high school. Fairfax County Public Schools' (FCPS) recent changes to TJ's admissions process specifically aim to reduce the number of Asian-American children-and only Asian-American children-who can attend TJ. The school district's race-based admissions scheme garnered nationwide interest and strong opposition from the Coalition for TJ, a group of over 5,000 parents, students, alumni, staff, and community members who advocate for school diversity and excellence through race-blind, merit-based admissions. Represented by PLF in federal court, the Coalition is challenging FCPS' race-based admissions scheme as a violation of the Fourteenth Amendment. PLF defeated the county's motion to dismiss and moved for a preliminary injunction, which was denied. The parties conducted extensive discovery and moved for summary judgment. The court granted PLF's motion for summary judgment and ordered the school board to stop using race-based admissions. The school board appealed to the Fourth Circuit, which stayed the district court order. PLF asked the Supreme Court to lift the stay, which was denied with three dissenting justices. The Fourth Circuit reversed. PLF will petition the Supreme Court for a writ of certiorari. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Cusano v. Cook County, Illinois. Cook County's Source Grow Grant Program, sought to provide $10,000 in grants paired with one-on-one business advising to "historically excluded businesses-including those owned by entrepreneurs of color, women, veterans, LGBQT+ and persons with a disability -to close racial wealth and opportunity gaps." Small business owners who apply for the program must indicate their race, and the application website indicates that the County will prioritize "historically excluded populations for selection, including People of Color, Women, Veterans, and Persons with a Disability." PLF sued the County on behalf of a class of small business owners to enjoin the racial preference on the basis that it violates the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. PLF sought class certification and moved for a preliminary injunction. Victory! The county rescinded its program and the case was dismissed. PLF did not seek or recover fees. Dalton v. Hao. Brian Dalton is a small business owner in Massachusetts trying to recover from the COVID-19 pandemic and the ensuing government orders that shuttered the state. PLF represents Brian in a federal lawsuit to challenge Massachusetts's eligibility preferences for businesses owned by racial minorities, women, or LGBTQs in its Inclusive Recovery Grant Program. The government's exclusion of Mr. Dalton due to his race, sex, and sexual orientation is unconstitutional under the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. If successful, this lawsuit will allow small businesses to compete on equal footing for much-needed COVID-19 relief grants and to vindicate small business owners' fundamental right to equality before the law. PLF moved for class certification. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Des Moines Midwife Collective v. Iowa Health Facilities Council. PLF represents Des Moines Midwife Collective, founded by registered nurses Emily Zambrano-Andrews and Caitlin Hainley, supports homebirth practice that honors the wishes of women of all income levels to give birth safely and comfortably outside of a hospital setting. Emily and Caitlin want to accommodate their growing clientele and broaden their range of childbirth options by opening a freestanding birth center. But Iowa's Certificate of Need law means they need permission from their competitors-namely, hospitals. PLF filed a lawsuit in state court challenging the CON law, seeking to alleviate the burden on Iowa's childbirth system and provide a safe, new choice for expecting mothers. The council removed the case to federal court. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees.</ExplanationTxt>
      </SupplementalInformationDetail>
      <SupplementalInformationDetail>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Form 990, Part III, Line 4a</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>Diemart v. City of Seattle. Joshua Diemert worked for the City of Seattle for 8 years, receiving good reviews and awards. Recently, however, he has been subjected to racially-motivated harassment under the city's "Race and Social Justice Initiative" (RSJI) that is sufficiently severe and pervasive to create a racially-hostile work environment. PLF filed a complaint on behalf of Joshua with the Equal Employment Opportunities Commission (EEOC), arguing that the city violated Title VII of the Civil Rights Act by requiring him to complete RSJI training, segregating staff meetings by race, offering and requiring race-based programming, promoting race-based affinity groups, and maintaining a commitment to making racial distinctions among City staff. The EEOC granted Joshua the right to sue. PLF filed a complaint in federal district court to vindicate Joshua's right to workplace equality and to protect everyone's right to be judged by the content of their individual character and work product, rather than being labeled and classified through the lens of discriminatory workplace equity initiatives. Because this matter is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Flores v. Bennett. PLF is providing local counsel to coordinate with attorneys from the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression to challenge Clovis Community College's refusal to allow a conservative student group to post anti-communist flyers on a campus bulletin board. Public universities cannot censor the speech of disfavored student groups because it finds the groups' message to be offensive. The lawsuit, which seeks a preliminary injunction, is filed in federal court in California. Because this matter is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Haile v. Hutchinson. PLF represents Stephen Haile, a longtime foster parent who housed and raised more than 300 foster children. Stephen has worked with social workers and served on a foster parent board and wishes to use this knowledge and leadership experience to serve on the Arkansas Social Work Licensing Board. However, the governor's ability to appoint members to the board is limited based on the race of the applicants. State law requires that no fewer than two African-Americans be appointed to the Board. Because Stephen is not African-American, and the only open seat was previously filled by an African-American member (one of two), Stephen's application will not be considered. PLF filed a lawsuit in federal court to challenge this blatantly unconstitutional race quota and sought a preliminary injunction. Victory! In response to the lawsuit, the state repealed the race quota. PLF dismissed the case without prejudice and did not seek or recover fees. Haltigan v. University of Santa Cruz. A growing number of universities employ Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) statement requirements as job screening tools. The University of California system uses these statements to screen for applicants from minority backgrounds and those committed to a certain view of racial justice. PLF represents J.D. Haltigan in a federal court challenge to a Diversity Statement Requirement in a job posting at the University of Santa Cruz. The requirement forces prospective professors to agree or at least pretend to agree to particular beliefs about race, fairness, and other subjects, as a condition of employment. Haltigan wants to be assessed on merit and qualifications, not an ideological litmus test. The case challenges the constitutionality of the diversity statements under the Equal Protection Clause and First Amendment. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Hierholzer v. Guzman. PLF represents Marty Hierholzer and his business, MJL Enterprises, a small business with 20 employees that contracts with federal agencies to provide maintenance products and equipment to VA hospitals and military facilities. On behalf of MJL Enterprises, PLF filed a federal lawsuit to challenge the Small Business Act's set-aside program for disadvantaged businesses, which authorizes the Small Business Administration to use racial preferences in establishing program eligibility. The SBA's use of race as the decisive factor in determining whether a small business is disadvantaged violates this constitutional promise of equality before the law. The lawsuit also challenges the agency's decisions-in the absence of congressional authorization-as to which racial groups are on the preferred list. This violates the separation of powers. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Hill v. Town of Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina. PLF represents Ami Hill, owner of #Bus252, a mobile art gallery, and the Muse Markets, which feature local artists and artisans selling their wares, filed a lawsuit challenging a town ordinance that requires itinerant vendors to donate 100% of their profits to charity in exchange for the right to sell during the summer tourism season. Alternatively, vendors can request a permit to operate from the Board of Commissioners, but they must undergo an arbitrary and unduly burdensome process each time they want to sell. The town also created a market in direct competition with Hill's Muse Market and town-sponsored vendors can sell year-round and keep their profits. The town rejected #Bus252's application to participate in the market. PLF filed a lawsuit in state court because the town cannot condition itinerant vendors' right to earn a living on surrendering profits or going to the Board of Commissioners for permission each time they want to sell. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Meland v. Padilla. In 2018, California enacted a woman quota law, which requires all publicly traded companies that are incorporated or headquartered in the state to have a certain number of females on their boards of directors. This law ignores that women are making great strides in the boardroom without a government mandate, and perpetuates the myth that women can't make it to the boardroom without government help. The law forces anyone selecting board members to consider them as members of a sex-based group, rather than as individuals. PLF's lawsuit on behalf of Creighton Meland challenges the state law as violating the Equal Protection Clause. The district court dismissed the case and PLF appealed. The Ninth Circuit reversed and remanded to the district court for consideration of the merits. PLF sought $552.10 in costs and recovered $47.10. On remand, PLF moved for a preliminary injunction, which was denied. PLF appealed to the Ninth Circuit and the case is stayed pending the result in related litigation. Litigation is ongoing, so it is premature to seek fees. National Center for Public Policy Research v. Weber. PLF represents NCPPR, a nonprofit that advocates against radical shareholder activism and in favor of basic principles like selecting board members of the merits and not based on their race. PLF filed a federal lawsuit challenging a California law that requires shareholders and publicly held corporations to elect a certain number of racial minorities and LGBT board members. After the court's adverse ruling on standing, PLF voluntarily dismissed the claims related to race and sexual orientation quotas and appealed the order as to the woman quota to the Ninth Circuit. PLF opposed the government's motion to stay this case, but the court granted it, and it is in abeyance. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Newell-Davis &amp; Sivad Home and Community Services, LLC v. Phillips. After two decades of working with special needs children, Ursula Newell-Davis decided to launch a company to provide respite services to this vulnerable population. But the state's Facility Need Review process stopped her because she failed to prove her proposed business was "necessary" despite evidence showing an increase in crimes by juveniles, pleas by city officials for more early intervention efforts for juveniles, and studies showing that respite care can improve outcomes for both children and their families. PLF represents Ursula in a federal lawsuit to challenge these arbitrary government restrictions that serve no legitimate purpose. PLF defeated the government's motion to dismiss, engaged in discovery, and moved for summary judgment. The trial court ruled in favor of the government. PLF appealed to the Fifth Circuit, which affirmed. PLF filed a petition for rehearing en banc, which was denied. PLF filed a petition for writ of certiorari. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees.</ExplanationTxt>
      </SupplementalInformationDetail>
      <SupplementalInformationDetail>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Form 990, Part III, Line 4a</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>Ng v. Board of Regents of University of Minnesota. PLF represents Evan Ng, a competitive gymnast since childhood. He chose to attend the University of Minnesota to compete on its century-old gymnastics team. His hopes were dashed when the university cut men's gymnastics after the 2020-21 school year under the mistaken belief that federal Title IX law requires the proportion of male athletes to match the proportion of males in the student body. Evan can no longer compete in his chosen sport and will lose out on valuable opportunities enjoyed by varsity athletes solely because the university believes it has too many men participating in sports. Because schools cannot make decisions that deny student-athletes' opportunities based on sex, PLF filed a complaint and sought a preliminary injunction in federal district court. The court denied the preliminary injunction and the Eighth Circuit affirmed. PLF filed a petition for rehearing en banc, which was denied. The case was subsequently voluntarily dismissed without prejudice. PLF did not seek or recover fees. Noland v. Montana Public Service Commission. After Noland Parker was medically discharged from the U.S. Army, he bought a few small dumpsters and a specialized truck and set out to become a hauler of construction debris. The Montana Public Service Commission issued a cease-and-desist order, saying he needed a certificate of public convenience and necessity (CON) before opening for business. After Parker filed for his certificate, the two largest waste companies protested his application. After a lengthy and costly legal battle, Parker withdrew his application. PLF represents Noland in a state court constitutional challenge to Montana's CON law for "junk haulers"-or Class D motor carriers-that allows entrenched companies to stop his business. He seeks to vindicate his right under both the Montana and U.S. Constitutions to earn an honest living without undue government interference. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees Ostrewich v. Scott. PLF represents Jillian Ostrewich, a Texas voter who went to her polling place wearing a firefighter union shirt. Election officials forced her to remove the shirt before being allowed to vote because the union supported an initiative measure on the ballot. In this follow-up case to PLF's Supreme Court victory in Minnesota Voters Alliance v. Mansky, PLF filed a complaint in federal district court arguing that a statute forbidding voters from wearing apparel related to any candidate, political party, or issue violates the First Amendment freedom of speech. After discovery, both parties moved for summary judgment, filed multiple briefs and presented oral argument. The district court struck down two of the electioneering statutes because they violate the First Amendment but upheld a narrower statute related to name badges. Both parties appealed and completed briefing in the Fifth Circuit. The appellate court upheld all three statutes. PLF will file a petition for rehearing en banc. Because litigation is ongoing, it would be premature to seek fees. Palmer v. Bonta. PLF represents nursing practitioners, each with a Doctorate in Nursing Practice, in a federal lawsuit challenging a California law that forbids them from using the title, "Dr." Their federal lawsuit seeks to vindicate their First Amendment right to truthfully use the title "Dr." so long as they clarify that they are not physicians. Plaintiffs face the threat of fines and loss of their licenses and livelihoods if the state enforces the law against them. The state cannot appropriate a commonly used term and reserve it for a narrow range of practitioners. Many professionals commonly use the title "Dr."-beyond physicians-and should be able to truthfully do so in describing their profession or accomplishments. Government censorship of professional titles is a thinly veiled attempt to protect well-connected industry insiders. PLF sought preliminary injunctive relief. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Pomeroy v. Utah State Bar. PLF directly represents Amy Pomeroy in the United States District Court for the District of Utah in the limited capacity of local counsel to the Goldwater Institute in their legal challenge to the Utah mandatory bar as violating the First Amendment rights of free speech and association. Because litigation is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Raak Law v. Gast. The Iowa Judicial Nominating Commission, which nominates judges to vacancies on the state's appellate courts, contains eight elected members-two in each of Iowa's four congressional districts. State law requires that each district be represented by one man and one woman and new commissioners can only replace one of the same sex. PLF represents one male and one female who are barred from running for commissioner solely because they would succeed commissioners of the opposite sex. PLF filed a federal lawsuit because this sex-based quota violates the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. The court denied PLF's motion for preliminary injunction and also Iowa's motion to dismiss. PLF appealed to the Eighth Circuit and sought an injunction. The injunction was denied. The parties stipulated resume litigation in trial court. Because litigation is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Roberts v. Basset. PLF represents Jonathan Roberts and Charles Vavruska in a federal lawsuit to challenge the New York Department of Health's protocols for making race a factor in the determination of who can access scarce COVID medications. Because Jonathan is 61 years old, fully vaccinated, and white, he is categorically ineligible to receive these COVID-19 treatments. Charles was hospitalized with COVID-19 in March 2020. As a fully vaccinated 55-year-old with one risk factor, he is eligible to receive COVID-19 treatments under New York's directives. Yet, because he is white, he is only eligible to receive these COVID-19 treatments after individuals who belong to a preferred racial group. PLF argues that medical eligibility decisions should be made on race-neutral scientific factors and that the current protocol violates the Equal Protection Clause. PLF sought a preliminary injunction. The court dismissed the case on standing grounds. PLF appealed to the Second Circuit, which affirmed the dismissal. PLF filed a petition for writ of certiorari. The petition was denied, but Justices Alito and Thomas issued a two-page dissent. The case is concluded. PLF did not seek or recover fees. Shirley v. Town of Farmville. PLF represents entrepreneur and barbeque master Mark Shirley and his food truck, Ole Time Smokehouse. In April 2021, the Board of Commissioners in Farmville, North Carolina, raised food truck permit fees from $100 per year to $75 per day, with trucks allowed to operate only two days per week. The board also increased the distance food trucks must keep from brick-and-mortar restaurants to 100 feet from a restaurant's property line. These new restrictions put the private downtown parking space Mark leased for the past two years too close to a nearby restaurant-which does not operate under a comparable rule-and would cost him $7,800 annually in permit fees to operate twice a week. He therefore moved his truck just outside of Farmville. PLF filed a lawsuit on behalf of Mark in state court to vindicate his fundamental right to earn a living free of irrational government interference and to protect the rights of future entrepreneurs. After discovery, the town agreed to repeal the unconstitutional ordinance amendments and PLF subsequently dismissed the case. PLF recovered $819.90 in costs and did not seek or recover attorneys' fees. Truesdell v. Friedlander. Phillip Truesdell and his family launched Legacy Medical Transport, non-emergency ambulance company in Aberdeen, Ohio, in 2017. The business has grown from one to seven vehicles. Located close to the Kentucky border, the company often takes clients from Ohio to Kentucky. Kentucky law, however, prohibits Legacy from returning those clients to Ohio without first obtaining a Certificate of Need. Certificate of Need laws grant existing businesses veto power over any new competition. PLF filed a complaint filed in federal court to vindicate Truesdell's right to earn a living free of irrational government interference. PLF and the state each moved for summary judgment. The court ruled in favor of the state. PLF appealed to the Sixth Circuit, briefed and orally argued. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees.</ExplanationTxt>
      </SupplementalInformationDetail>
      <SupplementalInformationDetail>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Form 990, Part III, Line 4a</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>Weiss v. Perez. Dr. Elizabeth Weiss, a highly decorated, fully tenured professor of anthropology at San Jose State University (SJSU), specializes in osteology-the study of human skeletal remains. She is an expert on the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act and similar laws that require laboratories and museums to hand over certain Native American remains to the tribes for reburial. Dr. Weiss' scholarship criticizes these laws as stunting scientific research and possibly unconstitutional. After she published a book in 2020, critics launched a campaign to label Prof. Weiss as anti-Indigenous and racist. SJSU joined the criticism, sponsoring a speaker series that called for shutting down views such as hers. The First Amendment protects Dr. Weiss' right to research, write about, and teach her views to her students. The university cannot silence her because it disagrees with her views. PLF represents Dr. Weiss in federal court, to defend her right to research, write, and teach differing perspectives, free of viewpoint discrimination and threats of retaliation. PLF defeated the university's motion to dismiss and proceeded to the merits. The case then settled. PLF did not seek or recover fees. Wynn v. Vilsack/Morton v. Vilsack/McKinney v. Vilsack/Dunlap v. Vilsack/Tiegs v. Vilsack/Morton v. Vilsack. PLF represents individual farmers in federal court in a series of cases challenging a provision of the American Rescue Plan Act of 2021 that allows loan forgiveness of up to 120%, but only for minority farmers and ranchers, whom the law automatically treats as "socially disadvantaged," regardless of their individual circumstances. Because government cannot use racial classifications to decide who gets government benefits and burdens, PLF filed cases in federal district courts in Florida, Illinois, Texas, Oregon, and North Dakota and sought to enjoin the government's enforcement of the discriminatory statute. The President signed legislation in August 2022, repealing the challenged provisions. Wynn v. Vilsack: Scott Wynn is a lifelong farmer who has run Wynn Farms in Jennings, Florida, producing sweet potatoes, corn, and cattle since 2006. COVID-19, however, hit the family's finances hard. Steep drops in beef prices and too little help and supplies to grow sweet potatoes meant less income, nearly all of which went toward federal farm loan repayment. Wynn is not eligible for farm loan forgiveness under the American Rescue Plan because he is white and therefore deemed not "socially disadvantaged." PLF successfully obtained a preliminary injunction and filed a motion for $127,709.05 in attorneys' fees, which is pending. PLF also sought $421.40 in costs. Morton v. Vilsack: Matthew and Joshua Morton are brothers and full-time farmers in Kell, Illinois. They have federal farm loans with an outstanding balance. At first encouraged about a farm loan forgiveness provision in Congress' COVID-19 legislation, Matthew and Joshua were surprised to learn they're not eligible-because they're white. The case was dismissed after the program's repeal and is now closed. PLF did not seek or recover fees. McKinney v. Vilsack: Jarrod McKinney began raising cattle in the Texarkana region eight years ago with help from a federal loan for beginning farmers. Like many farmers facing economic hardship in the pandemic's aftermath, Jarrod would apply for farm loan forgiveness but he is not eligible for the federal program-because he is white. The case was dismissed after the program's repeal and is now closed. PLF did not seek or recover fees. Dunlap v. Vilsack: Katie and James Dunlap are farmers in Oregon who both work two jobs in addition to raising their toddler. The couple rent land from his parents where they raise cattle and hay-an endeavor that required two farm loans to buy cattle and equipment. Like many other farmers, the Dunlaps were negatively affected by COVID and were relieved when they heard about a farm loan forgiveness provision in Congress' COVID-19-driven American Rescue Plan Act of 2021. But they were ineligible for the program because they are both white. The case was dismissed after the program's repeal and is now closed. PLF did not seek or recover fees. Tiegs v. Vilsack: When the pandemic struck, much of the U.S. agriculture industry felt the financial crunch. Julie Owen, James Tiegs, Abraham and Cally Jergenson, and Chad Ward were initially encouraged when Congress passed a COVID-19 relief law that included a farm loan forgiveness provision for economic hardship. But they each discovered that they are ineligible for the program for a single reason: They are white. The case was dismissed after the program's repeal and is now closed. PLF did not seek or recover fees. Miller v. Vilsack. Private counsel filed a class action lawsuit in a Texas federal district court challenging the American Rescue Plan Act of 2021, which contains racially discriminatory farm loan forgiveness provisions. Representing farmers and ranchers in various states who, with PLF counsel, also are challenging the Act, PLF moved to opt out of the certified class. Meanwhile, the parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment. The case was dismissed after the program's repeal and is now closed. PLF did not seek or recover fees. Amicus cases: PLF filed amicus briefs in the following cases, furthering the objectives described above. Allstates Refractory Contractors, LLC v. Walsh (Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals) American Forest Resource Council v. Pendley (D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals) Baker v. City of McKinney, Texas (Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals) Biden v. State of Nebraska (U.S. Supreme Court) Bindas v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Dept. of Transportation (Pennsylvania Supreme Court) Burgess v. FDIC (Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals) Cargill v. Haaland (Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals) Colorado v. Hill (Colorado Supreme Court) Consumers' Research v. Consumer Product Safety Commission (Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals) Culley v. Alabama/Sutton v. Alabama (U.S. Supreme Court) Demarest v. Town of Underhill (U.S. Supreme Court) Devillier v. State of Texas (U.S. Supreme Court) Gilmore v. Gallego (Arizona Court of Appeals) Gonzales v. Inslee (Washington Supreme Court) Greenberg v. Goodrich (Third Circuit Court of Appeals) Henderson, et al. v. Springfield R-12 School Dist. (Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals) Hunters Capital, LLC v. City of Seattle (Western District of Washington) James B. Nutter &amp; Co. v. County of Saratoga, NY (New York Court of Appeals) Legacy Foundation Action Fund v. Citizens Clean Elections Commission (Arizona Supreme Court) Lemon Bay Cove, LLC v. United States (Federal Circuit Court of Appeals) Loper Bright Enterprises, Inc. v. Raimondo (U.S. Supreme Court) Lucid Group USA, Inc. v. Johnston (Western District of Texas) Marfil v. City of New Braunfels (Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals) Mobilize the Message LLC v. Bonta (Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals; U.S. Supreme Court) Murphy Co. v. Biden (Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals) Nebraska v. Walsh (Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals) Porter v. Board of Trustees of North Carolina (Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals) Price v. Garland (U.S. Supreme Court) Pugin v. Garland (U.S. Supreme Court) (petition and merits stages) Raffensberger v. Jackson (Georgia Supreme Court) Recht v. Morrisey (U.S. Supreme Court) Sanchez v. Office of State Superintendent of Education (U.S. Supreme Court) SEC v. Cochran (U.S. Supreme Court) Sheetz v. County of El Dorado, California (U.S. Supreme Court) Smiley First LLC v. Massachusetts Dept. of Transportation (Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court) Texas v. EPA (D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals) Tiwari v. Friedlander (U.S. Supreme Court) Walton v. Neskowin Regional Sanitary Authority (Oregon Supreme Court; argued)</ExplanationTxt>
      </SupplementalInformationDetail>
      <SupplementalInformationDetail>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Form 990, Part VI, Section B, line 11b</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>The tax preparer and PLF financial management provide the Form 990 to the Audit Committee, along with each trustee, giving them the opportunity to raise any concerns and/or ask questions prior to the filing date. A deadline is given to the trustees to insure a timely filing of the tax return.</ExplanationTxt>
      </SupplementalInformationDetail>
      <SupplementalInformationDetail>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Form 990, Part VI, Section B, line 12c</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>PLF bylaws provide that any self-dealing transaction must be approved by a majority of the board, with the interested trustee(s) excluded from voting. The board must also conduct reasonable investigation and determine it could not have obtained a more advantageous arrangement. The Governance and Nominating Committee is charged with annual review of trustees including securing any disclosure of potential conflicts of interest with a written form signed annually by each trustee. Employees are required by our conflicts of interest policy to disclose to the Director of Human Resources any actual or potential conflict of interest which are then resolved by the President.</ExplanationTxt>
      </SupplementalInformationDetail>
      <SupplementalInformationDetail>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Form 990, Part VI, Section B, line 15</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>CEO compensation is reviewed annually by the Governance and Nominating Committee which makes recommendations to the full board to determine compensation. Job descriptions for the CEO and other key executives are evaluated against independent market sources and compensation data. PLF's independent board applies the "rebuttable presumption of reasonableness procedures in its evaluation of the compensation arrangements of key employees.</ExplanationTxt>
      </SupplementalInformationDetail>
      <SupplementalInformationDetail>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Form 990, Part VI, Section C, line 19</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>Copies are available on the organization's website or upon request.</ExplanationTxt>
      </SupplementalInformationDetail>
      <SupplementalInformationDetail>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Form 990, Part XI, line 9:</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>Change in value of split-interest agreements 226,818.</ExplanationTxt>
      </SupplementalInformationDetail>
      <SupplementalInformationDetail>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Form 990, Part XII, Line 2c:</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>The Foundation's Audit Committee assumes responsibility for oversight of the audit of the consolidated financial statements and selection of an independent accountant. The process is consistent with previous years.</ExplanationTxt>
      </SupplementalInformationDetail>
    </IRS990ScheduleO>
    <IRS990ScheduleR documentId="RetDoc1043400001">
      <IdDisregardedEntitiesGrp>
        <DisregardedEntityName>
          <BusinessNameLine1Txt>PLF Building LLC</BusinessNameLine1Txt>
        </DisregardedEntityName>
        <USAddress>
          <AddressLine1Txt>555 Capitol Mall Suite 1290</AddressLine1Txt>
          <CityNm>Sacramento</CityNm>
          <StateAbbreviationCd>CA</StateAbbreviationCd>
          <ZIPCd>958144605</ZIPCd>
        </USAddress>
        <EIN>471126088</EIN>
        <PrimaryActivitiesTxt>Property holding.</PrimaryActivitiesTxt>
        <LegalDomicileStateCd>CA</LegalDomicileStateCd>
        <TotalIncomeAmt>0</TotalIncomeAmt>
        <EndOfYearAssetsAmt>0</EndOfYearAssetsAmt>
        <DirectControllingEntityName>
          <BusinessNameLine1Txt>Pacific Legal Foundation</BusinessNameLine1Txt>
        </DirectControllingEntityName>
      </IdDisregardedEntitiesGrp>
      <SupplementalInformationDetail>
        <FormAndLineReferenceDesc>Part I, Line 1</FormAndLineReferenceDesc>
        <ExplanationTxt>The LLC was dissolved on 06/05/23.</ExplanationTxt>
      </SupplementalInformationDetail>
    </IRS990ScheduleR>
  </ReturnData>
</Return>
